Skip to content
Home/Blog/Treaty Relief
Treaty Relief

Coordinating Foreign Tax Credits Between the US and UK Across Two Tax Years

Coordinating foreign tax credits between the US and UK is mostly a question of order: which return is worked first, which figure feeds the other, and what happens when one side changes later. A first-year worked example, a sequencing table and a redetermination checklist.

Updated:November 9, 2026
Reading Time:11 min read
A large and a small brass gear meshing on a walnut desk in window light, for coordinating foreign tax credits US UK
Coordinating foreign tax credits between the US and UK works like meshing gears: each return turns on a figure the other one produces.

Coordinating foreign tax credits between the US and UK means working the two returns in a set order: the country that taxes an item of income first is settled first, and the other country then credits that tax in the right year. Get the order or the year wrong and the same pound of tax is relieved twice, or not at all.

Most guidance explains the two credit systems separately: Foreign Tax Credit Relief in the UK for US tax paid on one side and Form 1116 on the other. The harder part in practice is the hand-off between them, because the UK tax year runs from 6 April to 5 April while the US year is the calendar year. This guide is about that hand-off: who goes first, which year each credit lands in, what an arrival year looks like in figures, and how to repair the credit when one country changes its figure after the other return has gone in.

Why coordinating foreign tax credits between the US and UK is a sequencing problem

Each country's credit depends on a number produced by the other. The US cannot finish Form 1116 without the UK tax on the income, and HMRC cannot finish Foreign Tax Credit Relief without the US tax on income it also taxes. Neither credit can exceed the tax the crediting country charges on that same income, so each side also needs its own figure first.

The way out of that loop is the treaty's ordering. Article 24 of the 2001 UK/USA Double Taxation Convention gives one country the primary right to tax each kind of income and makes the other country give the credit. Once you know which country is primary for an item, you know which return has to be finalised first for that item. A single client can have items running in both directions in the same year, which is why US UK tax accountants work both returns from one file rather than handing a finished return from one team to the other.

Which return comes first for each type of income?

For a US citizen living in the UK, the UK goes first on UK-source income and the US credits it. On US-source investment income, the treaty sets a fixed order in Article 24(6), in which the UK credit is capped at the treaty rate before the US gives its own credit. The table below is the working order we use, item by item.

Income (US citizen, UK resident)Taxes firstCredit given byFigure that must be final first
UK salary under PAYEUKUS, on Form 1116 (general category)UK tax on the salary, from payslips or the year-end UK computation
UK bank interest and UK dividendsUKUS, on Form 1116 (passive category)UK tax on that income from the Self Assessment computation
US brokerage dividendsUS, but the UK credit is limited to the treaty rate for a non-citizenUK first (capped), then US for the UK tax left overThe capped US figure, then the UK tax after that credit
Non-US-source income the US taxes by reason of citizenship (the saving clause), such as UK rental profitUKUSUK tax; Article 24(6)(a) says the UK is not bound to credit the US tax on that income

The third row is where most mismatches start. Article 10 of the treaty caps US tax on portfolio dividends at 15% of the gross amount for a UK resident who is not a US citizen. Article 24(6) tells the UK to use that capped figure when it gives a US citizen credit, even though the US actually charges the citizen at full US rates. The US then credits the UK tax paid after that UK credit, treating the income as foreign source so the credit is not blocked. Our guide to double taxation relief between the US and UK walks through the articles; here the point is practical: for US dividends the UK figure is worked first, using a notional US figure, and only then does Form 1116 come together.

Which US year does UK tax belong to?

That depends on the method chosen on Form 1116. IRS Publication 514 (2025 revision) says a cash-method individual claims the credit in the year the tax is paid, unless they elect to claim it in the year it accrues. On the accrued method, foreign tax generally accrues on the last day of the foreign tax year. For the UK that day is 5 April.

  • Paid method: PAYE counts in the US year it is deducted from pay, and Self Assessment payments count in the US year they are made, whichever UK year they relate to.
  • Accrued method: the whole UK liability for 2025/26 accrues on 5 April 2026 and goes on the 2026 US return, including the tax on salary earned from April to December 2025.

The accrued election is made by ticking the box in Part II of Form 1116 on a timely filed original return. Publication 514 says it cannot be made on an amended return and must be followed in all later years. Our explainer on the UK tax year vs US tax year sets the two methods side by side for a settled resident. The rest of this guide deals with the year when the choice matters most: the year of arrival.

A worked example: the first year in the UK

Illustrative example: a US citizen moves to London and starts a UK job on 1 July 2025, paid monthly under PAYE. The figures are assumed for illustration and are not computed from any year's UK tax rates. Salary from July to December 2025 is £45,000, with £10,500 of PAYE deducted on those pay dates. Salary from January to March 2026 is £22,500, with £5,250 of PAYE. The UK liability for 2025/26 is settled entirely through PAYE at £15,750, and a further £16,000 of PAYE is assumed for April to December 2026 (the year is not over, so treat it as a projection). All UK tax is converted to dollars on Form 1116 at the rate Publication 514 requires for the method used.

US returnUK salary reportedUK tax credited: paid methodUK tax credited: accrued method
2025£45,000 (July to December 2025)£10,500 (PAYE deducted July to December 2025)£0 (nothing has accrued; the 2025/26 UK year ends on 5 April 2026)
2026£22,500 plus April to December 2026 salary£5,250 plus £16,000 (PAYE deducted in calendar 2026)£15,750 (the whole 2025/26 liability, accrued on 5 April 2026)
2027Calendar 2027 salaryPAYE deducted in calendar 2027The whole 2026/27 liability, accrued on 5 April 2027

Under the paid method the 2025 return matches tax to income almost exactly, because PAYE is deducted from the very salary the return reports. Under the accrued method the 2025 return reports £45,000 of UK salary with no UK credit at all, so US tax is payable on it. The 2026 return then receives £15,750 of credit against salary of which only part was earned in 2026, and the credit may well exceed the 2026 limit for the general category.

That excess is not lost. Publication 514 says unused foreign tax can be carried back one year and forward ten. Carried back to 2025, it can absorb the US tax paid on the July to December salary, but only by amending the 2025 return once the 2026 return is done, and the US tax paid in the meantime is cash out of pocket for a year or more. For a client arriving mid-year with salary only, the paid method is usually the cleaner route. The accrued method tends to earn its place later, for example where a large one-off gain will be taxed by the UK through Self Assessment long after the US return for that year. The comparison of the FEIE and the foreign tax credit in the UK covers the other choice that has to be made in the same arrival year.

Self Assessment payments complicate the paid method

The paid method stays tidy for PAYE. It gets lumpier once Self Assessment payments start. GOV.UK says payments on account are due on 31 January and 31 July, each usually half of the previous year's bill, with the balancing payment due on 31 January after the tax year. A single payment on 31 January 2027 can therefore hold the balancing payment for 2025/26 and the first payment on account for 2026/27. Under the paid method all of it is UK tax paid in 2027, but it has to be split by UK year and by Form 1116 category, because each part relates to different income. Our note on HMRC payments on account explains how those amounts are worked out.

How do US UK tax accountants run the two returns as one job?

By keeping one schedule for every tax payment in both countries and filing in an order that lets each return use the other's settled figures. A typical annual sequence for a US citizen employed in the UK with some investment income looks like this:

  1. January to March: collect US forms and UK payslips for the calendar year, and record each PAYE deduction and Self Assessment payment by date, UK tax year and Form 1116 category.
  2. By 15 April: estimate the US balance and pay it. The IRS page on the automatic 2-month extension for citizens abroad gives until 15 June to file, but interest runs on unpaid tax from the regular due date.
  3. April to June: work the UK computation for the year that ended on 5 April, at least far enough to fix the UK tax on each income item, including the capped treaty credit for US dividends.
  4. By 15 June: file the US return with Form 1116 using those UK figures, and Schedule B of Form 1116 to update the running carryover balance.
  5. Before 31 January: file the UK return, using the US tax for the two calendar years that overlap the UK year. GOV.UK sets the online deadline for 2025/26 at 31 January 2027, which is before the US return for calendar 2026 is due, so any US tax that has to be apportioned for the later calendar year is often an estimate that needs checking once the US return is final.
  6. After both are filed: compare the final UK figures with what the US return assumed, and correct any difference straight away rather than at the next year's return.

Step 5 needs care on the UK side. US tax for a calendar year straddles two UK tax years, and HMRC's International Manual at INTM161220 says any apportionment should generally be made by the number of days in the relevant periods, though another reasonable time basis applied consistently can be accepted. The manual treats tax withheld at the time of payment, as on a dividend, as straightforward to identify, because it attaches to the payment, so apportionment mainly arises where tax is charged by assessment for a different period. The same file serves both sides of our US individual tax return and UK Self Assessment work.

Currency belongs in the same schedule

Each payment should carry its date, because the date fixes the exchange rate. Publication 514 says paid taxes are translated at the rate on the date of payment, while accrued taxes generally use the average rate for the tax year they relate to, provided they are paid within 24 months after the end of that year. Our guide to IRS exchange rates for pounds covers where to find each rate.

What happens when the UK figure changes after the US return is filed?

The US credit has to be corrected. Publication 514 calls this a foreign tax redetermination: a change in foreign tax liability that affects US tax, including a refund of UK tax already credited, or accrued tax that ends up different from the amount paid.

The common UK triggers are an HMRC P800 calculation that refunds PAYE, an amended Self Assessment return, the outcome of an HMRC compliance check, and a balancing payment that differs from the figure the US return used under the accrued method. Here is the checklist we run when one arrives:

  • Identify the US year. Find the US return on which the changed UK tax was claimed as a credit: that is the year whose credit, and possibly whose carryover, has to be corrected.
  • Check the 24-month rule. Publication 514 says accrued tax not paid within 24 months after the end of the tax year to which it relates must be taken out of the credit until it is paid.
  • Notify the IRS in time. Where the UK tax went down, the publication generally requires notice by the due date, including extensions, of the return for the year the redetermination happened, and sets a penalty of 5% of the resulting tax due for each month or part of a month, up to 25%, for failing to notify without reasonable cause.
  • Claim the extra credit if the UK tax went up. Publication 514 gives 10 years from the regular due date of the return to claim a refund based on a larger foreign tax.
  • Update the carryover. Re-run Schedule B of Form 1116 for every later year the change touches, so the carryover balance stays right.

A small but useful exception: the publication says Form 1116 need not be attached for a year affected by a redetermination if the creditable taxes for that year come to $300 or less ($600 on a joint return) and the conditions for the exemption from the limit are met.

What people get wrong when coordinating US and UK credits

Using the P60 figure as the US credit

The P60 shows PAYE for the UK year to 5 April. It is the right figure for neither method: the paid method needs PAYE by calendar-year pay date, and the accrued method needs the final UK liability for the UK year, which can differ from PAYE once other income is added.

Claiming UK credit for the full US tax on US dividends

For a US citizen in the UK, HMRC's credit on US-source dividends stops at the treaty rate a non-citizen would pay. Claiming the full US tax on the SA106 overstates the UK credit and makes the US credit wrong too, because the US credits the UK tax after the UK credit.

Treating the accrued election as a one-year choice

Ticking "accrued" in an arrival year to tidy up one return commits every later return to the same method. It is a long-term decision and should be made on a projection of several years, not one.

Letting a P800 refund sit

A PAYE refund from HMRC is easy to bank and forget. If that PAYE has already been claimed as a US credit, the refund is a redetermination, and the notification duty runs whether or not anyone remembers it.

Getting both credits right

Coordinating foreign tax credits across the US and UK is less about knowing two sets of rules than about running them in the right order and keeping one schedule that both returns use. US/UK Cross Border Tax is US CPAs and UK tax advisers working as one team, in London, Manchester, New York and San Francisco, so the US return and the UK return come out of the same file. If you are in your first year in the UK, are weighing the accrued election, or have had a P800 or an HMRC amendment since your last US return, book a review of both returns before the next deadline.

Frequently asked questions

Which return should be prepared first, the US or the UK?

It depends on the income. For UK salary, UK rental profit and UK interest, the UK taxes first and the US credits the UK tax, so the UK figure has to be settled before Form 1116 is final. For US-source dividends of a US citizen living in the UK, the UK credit is capped at the treaty rate first, and the US then credits the UK tax that is left. In practice both returns are worked from one shared file.

Can I switch from the paid to the accrued method for my UK taxes?

Yes, a cash-basis individual can switch to the accrued method by ticking the accrued box in Part II of Form 1116 on a timely filed original return. IRS Publication 514 says the choice cannot be made on an amended return and, once made, must be followed in all later years. It is therefore a decision to make once, on a projection of several years.

Why does my first US return after moving to the UK show almost no foreign tax credit?

The usual reason is the accrued method. Publication 514 says foreign tax generally accrues on the last day of the foreign tax year, which for the UK is 5 April. UK tax for 2025/26 therefore accrues on 5 April 2026 and belongs on the 2026 US return, even though part of the salary it relates to was reported on the 2025 return. The unused credit can usually be carried back one year by amending.

What happens if HMRC changes my UK tax after I have filed my US return?

A change to UK tax already claimed as a credit is a foreign tax redetermination. IRS Publication 514 says you generally have to notify the IRS, usually with an amended return, and that failing to do so can lead to a penalty of 5% of the resulting tax due for each month or part of a month, up to 25%. If no US tax changes, the notice can be a Schedule C (Form 1116) attached to the return for the year the change happened. If the UK tax went up, you can claim the extra credit within the 10-year refund window the publication describes.

Does HMRC give credit for the US tax on my US income in the same tax year?

HMRC gives credit against UK tax on the same income, but the years have to be matched. HMRC's International Manual at INTM161220 says that where foreign tax is charged for a different period, it should generally be apportioned by days. US tax for a calendar year is therefore split across two UK tax years. Tax withheld at source, such as on a dividend, normally needs no apportionment.

Do I need Form 1116 if my only foreign tax is a small amount on UK dividends?

Possibly not. Publication 514 lets you claim the credit without Form 1116 if all your foreign income is passive, all of it and the tax are shown on a payee statement such as a Form 1099-DIV, the qualified foreign tax is no more than $300 ($600 on a joint return) and you elect the procedure. The catch is that no carryback or carryover is allowed to or from that year.

This article is general information, not personal tax advice. Thresholds, rates and deadlines change; confirm current figures on the official sources above and speak to a qualified US/UK tax adviser about your own circumstances.

Written by the US/UK Cross Border Tax team — US CPAs and UK tax advisers, London · Manchester · New York · San Francisco. About us. Last reviewed: November 9, 2026.

Have both credits checked together

US CPAs and UK tax advisers working as one team: we prepare your Form 1116 and your SA106 from the same schedule, so each credit lands in the right year.

Get a Fee Quote
Contact US/UK Cross Border Tax

Two Tax Systems, One Team

London Headquarters

4 Crown Place
London EC2A 4BT
United Kingdom

Manchester

CORE
Brown St, Manchester M2 1DH
United Kingdom

San Francisco

600 California St
San Francisco, CA 94108
United States

New York

33 Irving Pl
New York, NY 10003
United States

Start a Conversation