Skip to content
Home/Blog/US Tax Filing
US Tax Filing

Form 2555 Bona Fide Residence Test: When It Beats Physical Presence for Americans in the UK

The bona fide residence test is slower to qualify for but far more forgiving once you have it. Here is how Americans who move to Britain should sequence the two Form 2555 tests from the arrival year onward.

Updated:November 6, 2026
Reading Time:11 min read
Half-unpacked moving boxes and a grey throw in a bright London flat, the first year of a Form 2555 bona fide residence test
A new London flat is where a bona fide residence starts, but the Form 2555 test is only met once that residence spans a full calendar year.

The Form 2555 bona fide residence test lets a US citizen in the UK exclude foreign earnings once they have been a genuine UK resident for an uninterrupted period that includes a full calendar year. Trips home do not break it, which the 330-day physical presence test cannot offer. The catch is timing: in the year you arrive, you have not yet lived abroad for a full tax year, so the residence test cannot be met until the following December 31. This guide shows how to sequence the two tests from the year you move to Britain, using the 2026 figures in the IRS Instructions for Form 2555.

What is the Form 2555 bona fide residence test?

The bona fide residence test is a facts-and-circumstances test of whether you have made a real home in a foreign country. The IRS bona fide residence page says you meet it if you are a bona fide resident of a foreign country "for an uninterrupted period that includes an entire tax year." For a calendar-year filer, an entire tax year runs from January 1 to December 31.

Meeting the test is one of the conditions for the foreign earned income exclusion (FEIE), the foreign housing exclusion and the foreign housing deduction. You also need a tax home in a foreign country and foreign earned income. For 2026 the IRS sets the maximum exclusion at $132,900 per qualifying person, according to the What's New section of the 2026 Form 2555 instructions.

The bona fide residence test is claimed in Part II of Form 2555. Line 10 asks for the dates your residence began and ended, or "Continues" if you still live abroad. Lines 12a and 12b ask whether family lived with you. Lines 13a and 13b deal with any statement of non-residence you have made to the foreign country, which matters more for UK filers than most people expect (more on that below).

Who can use it

Two groups qualify under the 2026 instructions:

  • US citizens, wherever they live; and
  • US resident aliens, such as green card holders, who are citizens or nationals of a country with an income tax treaty in force with the United States.

The United Kingdom has a treaty with the US, so a British citizen with a green card who lives in London can use the test. A green card holder from a country without a US treaty cannot. They are limited to the physical presence test, which is open to every US citizen and resident alien. Our guide to US tax for green card holders living abroad covers the wider position for permanent residents who live outside the US.

How does the bona fide residence test differ from the physical presence test?

The physical presence test is a day count, and the bona fide residence test is an assessment of your intentions. IRS Publication 54 describes the physical presence test as requiring 330 full days in a foreign country during a period of 12 consecutive months. It "doesn't depend on the kind of residence you establish, your intentions about returning, or the nature and purpose of your stay abroad." The bona fide residence test is the opposite: intention and conduct are the whole test.

Point of differenceBona fide residence testPhysical presence test
What is testedA genuine foreign residence: intentions, home, family, visa, local tax330 full days in a foreign country in any 12 consecutive months
Who can use itUS citizens; resident aliens from treaty countriesAll US citizens and resident aliens
Minimum periodAn uninterrupted period including one entire tax yearAny 12-month window, which can straddle two tax years
Trips to the USBrief or temporary trips do not break itEach full day outside a foreign country counts against the 330
Earliest qualifying date after a mid-year moveDecember 31 of the following yearAbout 12 months after arrival
Weak pointA non-residence statement to HMRC, or a fixed-term assignmentLong or frequent US visits
Form 2555 partPart IIPart III

Verdict: the physical presence test is usually quicker in the year you arrive, and the bona fide residence test is usually safer for every full year after that.

The full-year rule and why the arrival year is different

The uninterrupted period for the bona fide residence test must include a full tax year. Once that is achieved, Publication 54 says you "figure the exclusions and/or the deduction from the date the residence actually began." The IRS adds that this means you could qualify for parts of one or two other tax years as well as the full year.

In practice, an American who arrives in London in August 2026 cannot meet the test until December 31, 2027, because 2027 is the first entire calendar year of UK residence. On that date the residence counts back to the August 2026 arrival, and the 2026 return can claim the exclusion for the part year. Until then, the arrival-year return has a timing problem, because it falls due long before December 31, 2027.

Two ways to handle the timing gap

The Form 2555 instructions give two options when you have not yet met either test by the due date of the first year's return, including the automatic two-month extension:

  1. File Form 2350 before the due date. Publication 54 says the extension is generally granted to 30 days beyond the date you can reasonably expect to qualify. The form must be filed by the return's due date, which is generally June 15 if your tax home and abode are outside the US and Puerto Rico. Interest still runs on unpaid tax from the regular April due date.
  2. File on time without the exclusion, then amend. You report worldwide income and pay the tax on it, then file Form 1040-X once you qualify to claim the exclusion and get the refund.

There is often a third, simpler route: qualify for the arrival year under the physical presence test instead, which can be met within about 12 months of arrival. We set out the deadline mechanics, including Form 4868 and the June 15 rule, in our guide to the US expat tax extension deadlines for 2026.

Worked example: a 2026 move to London, year by year

Illustrative example: a US citizen lands in London on July 31, 2026 on an open-ended employment contract, signs a two-year lease and has their spouse and child join them that autumn. Their first full day in the UK is August 1, 2026. They expect to spend about seven weeks in the US during 2027, across a family wedding in April, three weeks in the summer and the December holidays. Their UK salary is the equivalent of $150,000 a year. The figures below are illustrative and use the 2026 maximum exclusion of $132,900.

2026: the arrival year

The bona fide residence test cannot be met until December 31, 2027. The physical presence test can be met for the 12-month period from August 1, 2026 to July 31, 2027, provided they spend no more than 35 full days outside foreign countries in that window. The April 2027 wedding trip falls inside it, the summer trip should be booked to start on or after August 1, 2027, and the day budget then works.

Under the physical presence test, 153 days of that window fall in 2026 (August 1 to December 31). The maximum exclusion is prorated by qualifying days: $132,900 × 153 ÷ 365 = about $55,709. The 2026 return is due April 15, 2027, with the automatic extension to June 15, 2027 for someone living abroad. That date falls before July 31, 2027, so they file Form 4868 to extend to October 15, 2027 and file once the physical presence test is complete in August 2027.

2027: the first full year

Seven weeks in the US means the calendar year 2027 holds fewer than 330 full days abroad, so no 12-month physical presence window covering all of 2027 can work. A physical presence claim would exclude only part of the year. The bona fide residence test has no such problem. The trips are temporary, they return each time to the same London home, the family lives with them and they pay UK tax. On December 31, 2027 the test is met for the whole of 2027. The 2027 return, due June 15, 2028 under the automatic extension, can claim a full-year exclusion under Part II, using the 2027 limit once the IRS publishes it.

2028 onward

Line 10 of Part II shows a start date of July 31, 2026 and the word "Continues." Each year's return relies on the same residence. No day counts are needed, although keeping a travel log is still sensible if the IRS asks.

Tax yearTest usedDate the test is metFiling approach
2026 (arrival)Physical presence, August 1, 2026 to July 31, 2027July 31, 2027Form 4868 to October 15, 2027; file in August or September 2027
2027 (first full year)Bona fide residenceDecember 31, 2027File by June 15, 2028
2028 and laterBona fide residence, "Continues"Already metNormal expat deadlines

The alternative for 2026 would be Form 2350, waiting for the bona fide residence test and filing the 2026 return in early 2028. That can work, but it leaves a return open for almost two years, and interest runs on any unpaid 2026 tax from April 15, 2027. For most UK arrivals the split-test approach is cleaner.

Should an American in the UK use the FEIE at all?

Choosing the right test only matters if the exclusion is the right relief. UK income tax rates are often higher than the US federal rates on the same salary. Many Americans in Britain therefore get a better result from the foreign tax credit on Form 1116, which can also generate carryovers. The FEIE has costs that the Form 2555 instructions spell out:

  • you cannot take a credit or deduction for foreign taxes on income you exclude;
  • you cannot claim the additional child tax credit or the earned income credit in a year you claim either exclusion or the housing deduction; and
  • once chosen, the exclusion stays in effect for later years until revoked, and after revoking it you cannot claim it again for five tax years without IRS approval.

We compare the two reliefs with UK figures in FEIE vs foreign tax credit for Americans in the UK. The refundable credit point is covered in child tax credit for expats. If you do claim the exclusion, the residence test matters. If you claim the credit instead, Form 2555 is not filed and the test question disappears.

What evidence supports a UK bona fide residence?

The IRS decides bona fide residence largely on the facts you report on Form 2555, and it "cannot make this determination until you file Form 2555," according to its bona fide residence page. Publication 54 lists the type of quarters, whether your family went with you, the type of visa and the employment agreement among the factors. The instructions add that your acts carry more weight than your words. For a UK resident, the evidence that usually carries weight is:

  • a lease of 12 months or more, or a purchased home, rather than serviced or short-let accommodation;
  • a visa or status that allows an extended or indefinite stay, such as a Skilled Worker visa, a family visa or settled status;
  • an open-ended employment contract rather than a fixed project or secondment with a return date;
  • a spouse and children living with you, children in UK schools, registration with a GP;
  • UK tax paid as a UK resident under the HMRC Statutory Residence Test (RDR3); and
  • a US home that is let out or sold rather than kept waiting for you.

The weakest position is a fixed-term assignment. The IRS states that if you go to a foreign country to work for a specified period of time, "you ordinarily will not be regarded as a bona fide resident of that country," even if the work lasts a year or more. Someone on a two-year secondment from a US employer, with a US home kept vacant and a return date in the contract, is usually better off relying on the physical presence test.

The line 13 trap: statements to HMRC

Lines 13a and 13b of Form 2555 exist because of a specific rule. If you submit a statement of non-residence to the authorities of the foreign country and they hold that you are not subject to their income tax as a resident, you are not a bona fide resident there. The same applies while that statement is pending without an adverse decision. In UK terms, the residence status you report to HMRC on the SA109 residence pages must match the residence you claim to the IRS. If you tell HMRC you were not UK resident for a tax year so that foreign income falls outside UK tax, you cannot also claim to the IRS that you were a bona fide UK resident for the same period. This most often comes up in arrival and departure years, when the UK split-year rules and the US calendar year overlap.

What people get wrong about the bona fide residence test

  • Claiming it in the arrival year. The test cannot be met before a full calendar year of residence has passed. A 2026 return filed in spring 2027 that ticks Part II for an August 2026 arrival is claiming a test that is not yet met.
  • Assuming one year abroad is enough. The IRS is explicit that you do not become a bona fide resident "merely by living in a foreign country or countries for one year."
  • Counting days unnecessarily. Under the bona fide residence test, a long summer in the US does not break residence if you plainly intend to return. Day counts are a physical presence concern.
  • Forgetting the tax home test. Both tests also require a tax home abroad. The instructions say you do not have a foreign tax home for any period your abode is in the United States.
  • Treating it as UK residence. The UK Statutory Residence Test and the IRS bona fide residence test are separate. Being UK resident under the SRT is good evidence, but it does not decide the US question.

A short decision checklist

  1. Decide first whether the FEIE or the foreign tax credit gives the better result across the next five years. If it is the credit, stop here.
  2. Check eligibility: a US citizen, or a green card holder who is a national of a treaty country such as the UK.
  3. For the arrival year, map your travel. If a 12-month window with 330 full days abroad is achievable, use the physical presence test and extend with Form 4868 if needed.
  4. If it is not, choose between Form 2350 and filing without the exclusion and then amending.
  5. From the first full calendar year, move to the bona fide residence test if your facts support it, and keep your lease, contract and UK tax records together.
  6. Make sure nothing you file with HMRC states that you are not UK resident for a period you claim as bona fide residence.

How we help with Form 2555

US/UK Cross Border Tax is US CPAs and UK tax advisers working as one team, in London, Manchester, New York and San Francisco. We prepare the US and UK returns side by side, so the residence position on Form 2555 and on your Self Assessment agree. If you have just moved, or are unsure which test fits your year, our help with the Form 2555 bona fide residence test and the US return around it starts with a review of your dates and documents. See also our page for Americans living in the UK, our guide to digital nomad tax between the US and UK if you split your time, or contact us to book a call.

Frequently asked questions

What is the bona fide residence test on Form 2555?

The bona fide residence test is one of two ways to qualify for the foreign earned income exclusion on Form 2555. You meet it if you are a bona fide resident of a foreign country, such as the UK, for an uninterrupted period that includes an entire tax year. The IRS looks at your intentions and conduct: where you live, why you are there, whether your family came, your visa and whether you pay local tax.

Can a green card holder living in the UK use the bona fide residence test?

Only some can. The bona fide residence test is open to US citizens and to US resident aliens who are citizens or nationals of a country that has an income tax treaty in effect with the United States. A British citizen who holds a green card and lives in London is a national of a treaty country, so the test is available. Every resident alien can use the physical presence test instead.

Do trips back to the US break the bona fide residence test?

Not if they are brief or temporary and you clearly intend to return to your foreign home without unreasonable delay. The IRS says this applies even during the first full year of residence, and to business trips as well as vacations. That is the main practical advantage over the physical presence test, where each full day in the US reduces the 330-day count.

When can I file my first-year return if I am waiting for the bona fide residence test?

You can file Form 2350 by the return's due date, generally June 15 for Americans whose tax home and abode are abroad, to ask for an extension to about 30 days after you expect to qualify. Alternatively, file on time without the exclusion and claim it later on Form 1040-X. Either way, interest runs on unpaid tax from the regular April due date.

Does telling HMRC I am not UK resident affect the bona fide residence test?

Yes. Under the Form 2555 instructions, if you give the authorities of the foreign country a statement that you are not a resident there and they hold that you are not subject to their income tax as a resident, you are not a bona fide resident of that country. The same applies while that statement is pending. A non-residence claim to HMRC and a bona fide residence claim to the IRS cannot both stand.

Can I switch between the physical presence and bona fide residence tests?

Yes. Form 2555 asks you to qualify under one test for each year's return, and Publication 54 notes that spouses filing jointly need not use the same test. Many Americans in the UK use the physical presence test for their arrival year and the bona fide residence test for later years. Publication 54 lists the ways an exclusion is revoked, and changing the qualifying test is not one of them.

This article is general information, not personal tax advice. Thresholds, rates and deadlines change; confirm current figures on the official sources above and speak to a qualified US/UK tax adviser about your own circumstances.

Written by the US/UK Cross Border Tax team — US CPAs and UK tax advisers, London · Manchester · New York · San Francisco. About us. Last reviewed: November 6, 2026.

Not sure which Form 2555 test your year qualifies under?

Our US CPAs and UK tax advisers map your arrival dates, travel and UK residence, then prepare both returns so the Form 2555 claim and your HMRC filings line up.

Get a Fee Quote
Contact US/UK Cross Border Tax

Two Tax Systems, One Team

London Headquarters

4 Crown Place
London EC2A 4BT
United Kingdom

Manchester

CORE
Brown St, Manchester M2 1DH
United Kingdom

San Francisco

600 California St
San Francisco, CA 94108
United States

New York

33 Irving Pl
New York, NY 10003
United States

Start a Conversation