Skip to content
Home/Blog/UK Tax
UK Tax

Pension Carry Forward for Americans in the UK: Using Unused Allowance Without a US Tax Bill

UK pension carry forward lets you pay in far more than £60,000 in one tax year without an HMRC charge. For a US citizen, the treaty cap on the American side is a separate limit, and it is measured by calendar year. Here is how to plan a large contribution around both.

Updated:November 19, 2026
Reading Time:12 min read
A full glass jar of grain beside a nearly empty one on an oak shelf, picturing unused pension carry forward allowance
Pension carry forward works like the half-empty jar: allowance you did not use in the last three UK tax years can still be filled, but only in date order and only before it expires.

Pension carry forward lets you pay more than the £60,000 UK annual allowance into a pension in one tax year by using allowance you left unused in the previous three years. For an American in the UK it works the same way with HMRC, but the US treaty limit is separate, so a contribution can be clean in Britain and partly taxable in America. The fix is usually timing, and the deadline that matters most right now is 5 April 2027.

This guide covers the UK rules first, then what the US/UK treaty does with a large contribution, then a worked example showing how the same money can be paid in two ways with very different US results. It assumes you are UK resident and employed by a UK employer. If you are self-employed, read the section on who the treaty leaves out before you plan anything.

What is pension carry forward?

Pension carry forward is the UK rule that lets you add unused annual allowance from the three previous tax years to this year's allowance. You use the current year's £60,000 first, then the oldest earlier year, then the next. Nothing has to be claimed: if your pension savings fit within the total, no annual allowance charge arises.

The rule sits in sections 228A to 228C of the Finance Act 2004, and HMRC explains it in PTM055100. Three conditions catch people out:

  • Membership in each year. You can only carry forward from a tax year in which you were a member of a UK registered pension scheme, or a qualifying overseas scheme. An American who arrived in the UK in 2025 and joined a workplace scheme that year has no 2023/24 or 2024/25 allowance to bring forward, whatever their US 401(k) did.
  • Date order. GOV.UK's carry forward guidance says unused allowance is used from the earliest year to the most recent. You cannot choose to save the oldest year for later.
  • The money purchase annual allowance. If you have flexibly accessed a defined contribution pot, the £10,000 money purchase annual allowance applies and cannot be topped up by carry forward.

How much annual allowance can you carry forward into 2026/27?

For 2026/27 you can carry forward from 2023/24, 2024/25 and 2025/26. The standard annual allowance was £60,000 in each of those years, so the theoretical maximum available in 2026/27 is £240,000. In practice it is £60,000 plus whatever you did not use in each earlier year.

Tax yearStandard annual allowanceCan feed a 2026/27 contribution?Last year it can be used
2022/23£40,000No, already expired2025/26
2023/24£60,000Yes, used first2026/27 (ends 5 April 2027)
2024/25£60,000Yes, used second2027/28
2025/26£60,000Yes, used third2028/29
2026/27£60,000Current year, used before any carry forward2029/30

Figures from the GOV.UK pension schemes rates page, which also confirms the tapered annual allowance limits for 2026/27: threshold income of £200,000 and adjusted income of £260,000, with a minimum tapered allowance of £10,000. If the taper applied in an earlier year, the unused amount you carry forward is measured against your reduced allowance for that year, not £60,000.

Your "pension input" for each year is what counts. For a defined contribution scheme it is the total paid in by you and your employer. For a defined benefit scheme it is the growth in the value of your promised benefits, which your scheme administrator can tell you. Ask each provider for a pension savings statement for every year you plan to use.

Carry forward lifts the allowance, not your tax relief

This is the most common misunderstanding about the rule. Carry forward stops an annual allowance charge. It does not increase the tax relief you get on your own contributions, which GOV.UK caps at the higher of 100% of your UK taxable earnings for the year or £3,600. Someone earning £70,000 who personally pays in £150,000 gets relief on £70,000 at most, however much allowance they carried forward.

Employer contributions are different. They are not limited by your earnings, which is why large carry forward contributions are usually made by the employer, often through a bonus sacrifice. That route also matters for the US side, because Article 18(5) of the treaty only looks at contributions connected with UK employment.

How does the US treat a large UK pension contribution?

For a US citizen working for a UK employer, Article 18(5) of the US/UK treaty can keep both your own and your employer's contributions out of US taxable income. The relief is capped twice: the contribution must qualify for UK tax relief, and the US relief cannot exceed what the US would allow for a generally corresponding US plan.

The treaty text sets several conditions. The employment must be in the UK, the pay must be taxable in the UK and borne by a UK resident employer or a UK permanent establishment, and the contributions must be attributable to that employment. Paragraph 5(d) also requires the scheme to be one the US competent authority accepts as generally corresponding to a US plan.

Carry forward helps with the first cap. A contribution that would otherwise trigger an annual allowance charge arguably does not "qualify for tax relief in the United Kingdom", in the treaty's words, to the extent of the excess. Carry forward removes that excess, so the full contribution can qualify.

The second cap is where large contributions run into trouble. A common approach compares employer and employee contributions with the section 415(c) annual additions limit for US defined contribution plans. The IRS sets that limit at $72,000 for 2026 and, under Notice 2026-66, $75,000 for 2027. The elective deferral limit under section 402(g) is $24,500 for 2026 and $25,500 for 2027, and some advisers test employee-funded amounts against that lower figure as well. How a UK salary or bonus sacrifice should be classified for this comparison is a judgement call, and the position may need disclosure on Form 8833.

For the background on how a UK workplace scheme is treated year to year, see our guide to a UK workplace pension for a US citizen and our overview of UK pension tax treaty rules for US citizens.

Why the calendar year matters for pension carry forward

HMRC tests your pension savings over the UK tax year, 6 April to 5 April. The IRS limits run by calendar year. A single 2026/27 carry forward contribution therefore lands in one UK year but can fall in either the 2026 or the 2027 US year, depending on whether it is paid before or after 1 January 2027.

That mismatch is an opportunity. Splitting a large payment so that part goes in during December 2026 and part during January to March 2027 keeps it inside one UK tax year, where carry forward covers it, while spreading it across two US years, each with its own dollar limit. Remember that the 2027 calendar year also catches your regular contributions from April to December 2027, so leave room for them.

Pounds have to be converted to dollars to make the comparison. The IRS accepts its yearly average currency exchange rates for many purposes; our note on the IRS exchange rate for GBP explains when a spot rate is the better choice. A weaker dollar shrinks the headroom in sterling terms, so test the plan at a cautious rate.

A worked example: one bonus, two ways to pay it in

Illustrative example: an American engineer has worked in Bristol for a UK employer since 2022 and has been in the employer's defined contribution scheme throughout. Total pension inputs were £22,000 in 2023/24, £25,000 in 2024/25 and £28,000 in 2025/26. Regular contributions in 2026/27 are £28,000, paid evenly at about £2,333 a month. In 2026/27 they will receive a £60,000 bonus that they want to sacrifice into the pension. Their threshold income stays below £200,000, so the taper does not apply. The figures use an assumed rate of $1.30 to £1 throughout.

The UK side. Unused allowance is £38,000 from 2023/24, £35,000 from 2024/25 and £32,000 from 2025/26, which is £105,000 in total. Total 2026/27 input would be £88,000. The first £60,000 uses the current allowance, and the remaining £28,000 comes from the 2023/24 allowance. No annual allowance charge arises. The other £10,000 of 2023/24 allowance lapses on 5 April 2027, while all of 2024/25 and 2025/26 roll on.

The US side, option A: the whole bonus is paid in during March 2027.

  1. Calendar 2026 contributions are nine months of regular payments, about £21,000 or $27,300, comfortably under the $72,000 limit.
  2. Calendar 2027 contributions are £7,000 of regular payments from January to March, the £60,000 bonus, and about £21,000 of regular payments from April to December 2027. That is £88,000, or $114,400.
  3. Against the 2027 limit of $75,000, about $39,400 falls outside the treaty relief and is likely to be taxable as wages on the 2027 Form 1040.
  4. That slice carries no UK tax, because the UK relieved it, so there is no UK tax on it to credit. Any excess foreign tax credits carried from earlier years may absorb some of the US tax, but often not all of it.

Option B: £32,000 of the bonus is sacrificed in December 2026 and £28,000 in March 2027.

  1. Calendar 2026 contributions become £53,000, about $68,900, which is under the $72,000 limit.
  2. Calendar 2027 contributions become £56,000, about $72,800, which is under the $75,000 limit.
  3. The UK result is identical, because both payments fall in the 2026/27 tax year.

Same money, same UK result, and a US difference of roughly $39,400 of income. The example only works if the employer can pay part of the bonus early, and the margins are thin: at a rate of $1.36 to £1 the 2027 total in option B would exceed the limit. If you apply the 402(g) deferral limit to sacrificed salary and bonus, the headroom is far smaller, so treat the example as a method rather than a promise.

Who the treaty relief does not reach

Article 18(5) is written for UK employment. Several groups of Americans in Britain can use pension carry forward with HMRC but get no matching US exclusion:

  • Self-employed people paying into a SIPP or personal pension. Their contributions are not attributable to employment, so carry forward reduces UK tax but the US gives no deduction. Our guide to SIPP US tax reporting covers how the pot itself is reported.
  • Employees of a US company with no UK establishment, where the salary is not borne by a UK resident employer or a UK permanent establishment.
  • Personal contributions outside payroll. Whether a personal top-up to a workplace scheme or a SIPP is "attributable to the employment" is open to argument and needs careful review.

For these groups, a large carry forward contribution can still make sense in UK terms, but it should be sized with the US tax cost in view, not just the UK saving.

How to plan a pension carry forward contribution: step by step

  1. Gather pension input amounts for 2023/24, 2024/25 and 2025/26 from every scheme, including any defined benefit accrual, and confirm you were a member in each year.
  2. Check the taper for each of those years and for 2026/27, using threshold income and adjusted income. A tapered year carries forward less.
  3. Check flexible access. If you have taken a flexible payment from any defined contribution pot, the money purchase annual allowance limits you instead.
  4. Separate employer and personal money. Keep personal contributions within 100% of your UK earnings and route any larger amount through the employer.
  5. Map each payment to a US calendar year and convert at a cautious exchange rate. Include regular contributions for the whole calendar year, not just the UK tax year.
  6. Confirm the US position under Article 18(5), decide how sacrificed pay is classified, and decide whether Form 8833 disclosure is needed.
  7. Pay in before 5 April 2027 if you want to use 2023/24 allowance, allowing for payroll cut-off dates, which often fall weeks earlier.

What people get wrong about carry forward

  • Treating the £60,000 as the ceiling. The allowance is often far higher once unused years are counted, and some people pay an annual allowance charge they could have avoided. When that happens, the charge goes on the Self Assessment return; our guide to Self Assessment for US citizens in the UK covers the return itself.
  • Assuming UK relief means US relief. The US cap is separate and smaller than many carry forward plans.
  • Counting 2022/23. For 2026/27 contributions that year has already dropped out.
  • Forgetting the FBAR and Form 8938. A larger pension balance is still a foreign account or asset to report, whatever the income tax position.

For other moves to make before the tax year ends, see our US/UK year-end tax planning guide.

What to do next

If you have spare allowance from 2023/24, the window closes on 5 April 2027, and a payment split around 1 January needs to be agreed with your employer and payroll well before the end of December 2026. Gather your pension savings statements first; the rest of the analysis depends on them.

US/UK Cross Border Tax is a team of US CPAs and UK tax advisers working as one team, with offices in London, Manchester, New York and San Francisco. Our US/UK pension tax advice covers carry forward calculations, the Article 18(5) position and both returns together, and we work with many Americans living in the UK. To plan a contribution before the deadline, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

How does pension carry forward work in the UK?

Pension carry forward lets you use annual allowance you did not use in the three previous tax years once you have used up the current year's allowance. GOV.UK says the earliest year is used first, you do not need to tell HMRC, and you must have been a member of a UK registered pension scheme in each year you carry from. If your savings still exceed the total, the excess is charged to tax.

Can a US citizen living in the UK use pension carry forward?

Yes. Pension carry forward is a UK rule that depends on UK scheme membership and UK tax relief, not on nationality, so a US citizen who is UK resident uses it in exactly the same way as a British colleague. The difference is on the US return, where the treaty relief for UK pension contributions has its own limit and can leave part of a large contribution taxable in America.

Does Article 18(5) of the US/UK treaty cover carry forward contributions?

Article 18(5) covers contributions only to the extent they qualify for UK tax relief, and carry forward is what stops a large contribution triggering the UK annual allowance charge. The treaty then caps the US relief at what the US would allow for a generally corresponding US plan. So a carry forward contribution can be fully relieved in the UK yet only partly excluded from US income.

When does unused annual allowance from 2023/24 expire?

Unused annual allowance from 2023/24 can be carried forward only into the three following tax years, the last of which is 2026/27. The 2026/27 tax year ends on 5 April 2027, so any part of the 2023/24 allowance still unused after a contribution made by that date is lost. The 2023/24 allowance was £60,000, so the amount at stake can be large.

Can I use carry forward if I have flexibly accessed my pension?

Not for money purchase savings. Once you have flexibly accessed a defined contribution pension, the money purchase annual allowance of £10,000 for 2026/27 applies, and GOV.UK confirms you cannot carry forward unused money purchase annual allowance. Carry forward still works against the alternative annual allowance, which mainly matters if you also build up defined benefit savings.

Do I need to report pension carry forward on my Self Assessment return?

No, provided carry forward covers the excess in full. HMRC's Pensions Tax Manual says unused allowance is carried forward automatically and does not need to appear on the return when no annual allowance charge is due. Keep your own working, with each year's pension input amounts, because you will need it if HMRC asks and when you prepare the US return.

This article is general information, not personal tax advice. Thresholds, rates and deadlines change; confirm current figures on the official sources above and speak to a qualified US/UK tax adviser about your own circumstances.

Written by the US/UK Cross Border Tax team — US CPAs and UK tax advisers, London · Manchester · New York · San Francisco. About us. Last reviewed: November 19, 2026.

Planning a pension carry forward contribution?

We work out your unused UK allowance, test it against the US treaty limit for each calendar year, and prepare both returns so the numbers agree.

Get a Fee Quote
Contact US/UK Cross Border Tax

Two Tax Systems, One Team

London Headquarters

4 Crown Place
London EC2A 4BT
United Kingdom

Manchester

CORE
Brown St, Manchester M2 1DH
United Kingdom

San Francisco

600 California St
San Francisco, CA 94108
United States

New York

33 Irving Pl
New York, NY 10003
United States

Start a Conversation