Tax Specialists for US/UK Investors: PFICs, ISAs and Brokerage Accounts
The same £19,200 gain can cost 15% or more than 40% depending on what you held and where you held it. Here is the comparison a good adviser should run for you, and seven questions that show whether they can.

Tax specialists for US/UK investors take a portfolio apart holding by holding, test each fund, share and account under both the US PFIC rules and the HMRC offshore fund rules, and then work out what each sale or election would really cost. If an adviser cannot show you that calculation in numbers, you are paying for a warning and not for advice.
Most writing on this subject explains what a PFIC is and tells you to avoid UK funds. Our own guides do that too, including why an ISA can be a problem on your US return and how the reporting fund rules collide with PFIC status. This post answers the next question: what should you expect from the person handling your portfolio, and how do you test them before you sign?
What do tax specialists for US/UK investors do that a general accountant doesn't?
A specialist applies two unrelated tests to the same holding and acts on the combined result. The US asks whether a foreign fund is a passive foreign investment company. The UK asks whether an offshore fund has reporting status. Neither answer changes the other.
The US test comes first. A foreign corporation is a PFIC if 75% or more of its gross income is passive, or if at least 50% of its assets on average produce passive income, according to the IRS instructions for Form 8621. A pooled UK or Irish fund will commonly meet those tests. The UK test then runs in the opposite direction. HMRC's helpsheet HS265 explains that a gain on a non-reporting offshore fund is normally an offshore income gain, charged to Income Tax and not Capital Gains Tax. A US-domiciled ETF counts as offshore from the UK's point of view.
A UK accountant will usually see only the second test, and a US preparer only the first. A team that covers both, such as our tax specialists for US/UK clients, should be able to place each holding in a table and price it.
The comparison a good adviser should run: one gain, six outcomes
The table below is our own worked example. It shows why the question "is my ISA tax free?" is too narrow. The same gain is held in six different ways.
Illustrative example: a US citizen living in Leeds invests £32,000 in January 2023 and sells for £51,200 in December 2026, a gain of £19,200. We assume an invented, unchanged rate of £1 = $1.25, so the gain is $24,000. The investor is a UK higher rate taxpayer with the whole gain in that band, has no other gains and has not used the £3,000 exempt amount. On the US side the investor is in the 24% bracket, pays the 15% long-term rate and has income below the Net Investment Income Tax threshold. Dividends, fund charges and interest are left out.
| What was held, and where | UK tax | US tax after credit | Total | Share of gain |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Individual share in an ISA | $0 | $3,600 | $3,600 | 15% |
| Individual share in a general account | £3,888 ($4,860) | $0 expected | $4,860 | 20.25% |
| US ETF with HMRC reporting status | £3,888 ($4,860) | $0 expected | $4,860 | 20.25% |
| UK fund in an ISA, no PFIC election | $0 | $8,100 plus interest | $8,100 plus interest | 33.75% plus |
| UK reporting fund in a general account, no PFIC election | £3,888 ($4,860) | $3,240 to $8,100 plus interest | $8,100 to $12,960 plus interest | 33.75% to 54% plus |
| US ETF without HMRC reporting status | £7,680 ($9,600) | $0 expected | $9,600 | 40% |
How those figures are built
- UK Capital Gains Tax: (£19,200 less £3,000) at 24% is £3,888. GOV.UK gives both the 24% rate and the £3,000 allowance for 2026 to 2027.
- Offshore income gain: £19,200 at the 40% higher rate for 2026/27 is £7,680, with no Capital Gains Tax exempt amount to set against it.
- US long-term gain: $24,000 at 15% is $3,600. IRS Topic 409 sets out the long-term rates. Where UK tax was paid, we expect the foreign tax credit to cover this, subject to the Form 1116 limit.
- PFIC with no election: the gain is spread evenly over four years at $6,000 a year. The 2026 slice is ordinary income at 24%, or $1,440. Each of the three earlier slices is taxed at that year's highest rate, which we take as 37%, or $2,220 each and $6,660 together. That gives $8,100 before the interest charge. The method is in the Form 8621 instructions, and we walk through it further in our PFIC tax calculation guide.
The range in the fifth row exists because foreign tax on an excess distribution only reduces the increase in tax for its own year, and the Form 8621 instructions allow no carryover of the unused part. If all the UK tax is usable, the total stays at $8,100. If none is, it reaches $12,960. An adviser should tell you where in that range you fall. It also shows the point most summaries skip: at this gain, the general account does not beat the ISA for a UK fund. Both are poor, for different reasons.
What the table should change
Look at the first and fourth rows. Both sit in an ISA, and both pay no UK tax. The wrapper is the same, yet one costs more than twice as much because of what is inside it. The ISA was never the main variable. The holding was. There is one caveat: whether an ISA should also be treated as a foreign trust is not settled, because we are not aware of IRS guidance written specifically for ISAs. Your adviser should state a position on it and explain why.
Seven questions to ask a specialist before you sign
These test real working knowledge, and you can ask them on a first call. For wider checks on qualifications, see our guide to the credentials behind the letters.
| Ask this | A strong answer | A warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Here is one fund I own. What is it on each side? | Asks for the ISIN, then checks domicile, PFIC status and the HMRC list | Answers without asking which fund it is |
| Which PFIC methods are open to me? | Compares section 1291, QEF and mark-to-market against the fund's facts | "Just sell it" |
| What will selling cost me, in dollars? | Offers a lot-by-lot calculation before you act | Talks only about "high tax rates" |
| Does reporting status fix my PFIC? | No: separate regimes, separate tests | Treats them as one issue |
| How do you handle the two tax years? | Maps each sale to its UK year and its US year before relying on a credit | Finishes one return with no view of the other |
| How do you work out my gain in each currency? | Separate dollar and sterling figures from the trade-date records | Converts one final gain at one rate |
| What about my past filings? | Reviews them first, and raises options if forms were missed | Starts this year and ignores the rest |
How much work is the PFIC reporting, and why does it drive the fee?
PFIC reporting is expensive because each fund is its own calculation. A separate Form 8621 is needed for each PFIC, and the IRS's own burden estimate for most filers is 16 hours 58 minutes of recordkeeping, 11 hours 24 minutes learning about the law or the form, and 20 hours 34 minutes preparing and sending it. That comes to 48 hours 56 minutes per form, according to the Form 8621 instructions.
An adviser will not bill those exact hours, since software and experience shorten the work. The number still explains why a portfolio of eight funds costs far more to report than one of eight shares, and why consolidating is sometimes worth paying for. Ask for a fee per fund, and ask what happens to the fee if you reduce the number of funds. Also ask about the limited exception. The IRS lets a shareholder skip the Part I report for a section 1291 fund where total PFIC stock is worth $25,000 or less at year end, or $50,000 on a joint return, provided there is no excess distribution. A sale at a gain ends that relief for the year.
What the work should look like, step by step
Our PFIC reporting service follows this order, and it is a reasonable standard to hold any firm to.
- Build one holdings register. List every account and position with the ISIN, domicile, purchase lots, and values in both currencies.
- Classify each holding twice. Record its US status (PFIC or not, and any election) and its UK status. HMRC's list of approved reporting funds is updated monthly, and the last update at the time of writing was 12 October 2026, so check it rather than relying on memory.
- Check the election routes. A QEF election needs a PFIC Annual Information Statement from the fund, or an Annual Intermediary Statement in some cases. A mark-to-market election needs marketable stock, meaning regularly traded on a qualifying exchange. Our mark-to-market guide covers when that helps.
- Price the options. Compare holding, selling now and selling later for each lot, in a table like the one above, using your real figures.
- Sequence the sales. Decide on timing across the two tax years, explained below.
- Reconcile the account reporting. An FBAR is required when combined foreign accounts exceed $10,000 at any time in the year. For filers living abroad, Form 8938 applies above $200,000 at year end or $300,000 at any time if single, and $400,000 or $600,000 on a joint return. Assets already reported on Form 8621 are not listed a second time, but they still count toward the threshold.
- Agree a buying rule. Leave with a short written note of what you can buy from now on. Our guide to investing as an American in the UK is a useful starting point.
Where do brokerage accounts go wrong on both returns?
Brokerage accounts usually go wrong on the timing and the currency, because the broker's annual statement matches neither return. The US year ends on 31 December and the UK year on 5 April. A sale on 20 January 2027 falls in the US 2027 year and the UK 2026/27 year, so the UK tax that might support a credit can arrive on a different timetable from the US liability. That is why step 5 exists.
Currency adds a second layer. HMRC's Capital Gains Manual at CG78310 says amounts must be converted into sterling when they are incurred or received, citing Bentley v Pike and Capcount Trading v Evans. It rejects working out the gain in the foreign currency and converting at the end. The US return does the same exercise in dollars, so one sale can give a gain on one return and a loss on the other. We assumed a flat exchange rate above only to keep the arithmetic clear; real files rarely behave that way. Our note on UK Capital Gains Tax for US citizens gives an example.
Higher earners have a third point to check. The Net Investment Income Tax is 3.8% where modified adjusted gross income exceeds $200,000 if single or $250,000 on a joint return, and it covers dividends, interest and capital gains. A good file tests it separately rather than assuming that foreign tax credits have dealt with everything. Our high net worth clients often meet this first when they sell a large position.
Common mistakes when hiring an adviser for an investment portfolio
- Sharing only the accounts you think matter. A forgotten workplace share plan or a junior account changes the reporting. Give the adviser everything once, then let them decide what is relevant.
- Selling before asking. A sale cannot be undone in a later year. Get the calculation first.
- Assuming that software classified your funds. Expat tax software generally relies on what you enter. If a UK fund goes in as an ordinary holding, nothing corrects it for you. See our comparison of software and specialists.
- Hiring for one side only. Advice to move into US ETFs can solve the PFIC issue and create an offshore income gain. Advice to use a UK fund can do the reverse. Each is only half of the answer.
You may not need ongoing help at all. If you are an American in the UK with a small number of individual shares, no funds and tidy records, a single review may be enough. If you hold funds, have unreported years or expect a large sale, talk to us before you trade. US/UK Cross Border Tax has US CPAs and UK tax advisers working as one team, across London, Manchester, New York and San Francisco.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a specialist if I only hold individual shares?
Often the need is smaller, because individual company shares are generally not funds and do not raise the usual PFIC question, although a foreign company can still meet the PFIC tests. You still report dividends and gains to both countries, in dollars and in pounds, and may need an FBAR and Form 8938. Many investors with a simple share portfolio need a one-off review and a sound set of records rather than a complex annual engagement.
Should I sell the UK funds in my ISA straight away?
Not automatically. Selling inside the ISA creates no UK tax, but on the US side a gain on a PFIC with no election is generally treated as an excess distribution, so the sale crystallises the charge. Before selling, a specialist should compute that charge for each purchase lot, check earlier filings and any elections, and compare it with the expected cost of holding. The result can differ sharply between a two-year-old fund and a twelve-year-old one.
Can a US citizen in the UK keep using a US brokerage account?
Some can, but the answer depends on the broker, because firms set their own policies for clients living abroad and some restrict or close such accounts. Ask the broker in writing before you move or change address. The tax position is separate: a UK resident reports the account's income and gains to HMRC, and a US-domiciled ETF should be checked against HMRC's list of reporting funds before you buy it.
What records should I bring to a first meeting about my investments?
Bring year-end statements for every account, the transaction history for each fund and share, and copies of past US and UK returns, including any Form 8621 or FBAR. Add the fund's ISIN, which lets an adviser check its domicile and HMRC reporting status. Trade dates matter as much as amounts, because the US and UK calculations each convert purchase and sale values at the exchange rate for the date of each transaction.
How can I tell whether an adviser really understands PFICs?
Ask the adviser to explain, for one fund you own, the difference between the default section 1291 method, a qualified electing fund election and a mark-to-market election, and which are open to you. Then ask whether the fund issues a PFIC Annual Information Statement and whether it is listed on an exchange. A capable adviser answers from the fund's own facts. A weak answer is a general warning to avoid funds, with no calculation behind it.
Does the $25,000 PFIC exception mean no Form 8621 is needed?
It can remove the filing requirement in a limited case. The IRS exception applies to section 1291 funds where total PFIC stock is worth $25,000 or less at year end, or $50,000 on a joint return, and there is no excess distribution or gain treated as one. It stops applying when you sell at a gain, so it does not solve the tax problem. It also does not remove your FBAR obligations or your other reporting.
Official sources
- IRS — Instructions for Form 8621 (Rev. December 2025)
- GOV.UK — HS265 Offshore funds helpsheet
- GOV.UK — Approved offshore reporting funds
- GOV.UK — Capital Gains Tax rates and allowances
- GOV.UK — Income Tax rates and Personal Allowances
- IRS — Topic no. 409, Capital gains and losses
- IRS — Federal income tax rates and brackets
- IRS — Net Investment Income Tax
- IRS — Summary of FATCA reporting for US taxpayers
- IRS — Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR)
- HMRC — Capital Gains Manual CG78310, foreign currency
This article is general information, not personal tax advice. Thresholds, rates and deadlines change; confirm current figures on the official sources above and speak to a qualified US/UK tax adviser about your own circumstances.
Written by the US/UK Cross Border Tax team — US CPAs and UK tax advisers, London · Manchester · New York · San Francisco. About us. Last reviewed: November 1, 2026.
Want your portfolio priced on both sides?
Send us your holdings and we will show you how each one is treated by the IRS and HMRC, and what your options cost, before you sell anything.
Get a Fee QuoteTwo Tax Systems, One Team
Email Us
hello@usukcrossbordertax.comLondon Headquarters
4 Crown Place
London EC2A 4BT
United Kingdom
Manchester
CORE
Brown St, Manchester M2 1DH
United Kingdom
San Francisco
600 California St
San Francisco, CA 94108
United States
New York
33 Irving Pl
New York, NY 10003
United States