Skip to content
Home/Blog/Choosing an Adviser
Choosing an Adviser

Tax Specialists for US/UK Pensions: Who Should Handle Your SIPP and 401(k)?

A pension decision is made once and taxed twice. Here is what a pension-focused cross-border adviser should check before you contribute, transfer or draw, a worked example of one lump sum with three different US answers, and how to test an adviser before you hire them.

Updated:November 6, 2026
Reading Time:11 min read
Small olive tree in a terracotta pot on a sunlit windowsill, a quiet image for tax specialists for US/UK pensions.
A pension grows slowly over decades, so tax specialists for US/UK pensions plan each withdrawal so that both tax systems are settled before money leaves the pot.

Tax specialists for US/UK pensions work out what a contribution, transfer or withdrawal will cost under both the US and UK rules before the money moves, take a documented treaty position on each pension, and keep the reporting on both returns consistent year after year. If an adviser can only tell you how one country treats your SIPP or 401(k), you are getting half the answer.

Pensions are where cross-border mistakes are hardest to undo. A wrong FBAR can be amended. A lump sum, once paid, cannot be unpaid. We have already written about the rules themselves, from how the treaty treats UK pensions to what a SIPP means on a US return. This guide covers the next question: what should a specialist actually do for you, and how can you tell whether the one in front of you is up to it?

What do tax specialists for US/UK pensions actually do?

A pension specialist on a cross-border team does three jobs: plans each pension event before it happens, takes and records a treaty position for each pot, and keeps the reporting consistent on both returns. A general accountant in either country usually does only the third, and only for one country.

The planning matters because the two systems treat the same event differently. The UK gives tax relief on most pension contributions and taxes most withdrawals as income, with a tax-free element. The US starts from the view that a foreign pension is a foreign account and a foreign trust, and then lets the US-UK income tax treaty change that answer in specific cases. A specialist has to know which treaty paragraph applies, and whether the saving clause in Article 1(4) takes the benefit away again for a US citizen.

Our Tax Specialists for US/UK clients usually come to us with a mix of pots: a UK workplace scheme, a SIPP, a 401(k) or IRA left in the US, and sometimes a UK final salary scheme. Each one needs its own answer.

Five pension events and what each one needs checked

The table below is our own working checklist. It lists the events that most often produce a tax bill or a reporting gap, and the question that must be answered on each side before you act.

Pension eventUK questionUS questionCommon mistake
Paying into a UK workplace pensionIs the contribution within the annual allowance?Does Article 18(5) exclude it from US income, and up to what limit?Excluding the full contribution with no check against US limits
Paying into a SIPP personallyRelief at source and higher rate relief claimed on Self AssessmentIs there any treaty relief at all for a personal contribution?Assuming UK relief means US relief
Taking the tax-free lump sumIs it within the lump sum allowance?Which treaty position is taken, and can foreign tax credits help?Leaving the lump sum off the US return with no disclosure
Drawing from a 401(k) or IRA while UK residentTaxed as pension income under Article 17(1)(a)Taxed as a citizen, with a credit for UK taxDouble tax because the credit is not matched to the right year
Transferring a pension across the borderIs the receiving scheme a QROPS, and does the 25% charge apply?Is the transfer a taxable distribution?Signing the transfer before either calculation is done

Three of those rows turn on one figure set by GOV.UK. The annual allowance is £60,000 for 2026/27, tapered for people with threshold income above £200,000 and adjusted income above £260,000. The lump sum allowance is £268,275, the most that most people can take tax-free across all their UK pensions. A specialist should know where you stand against both before advising on the US side.

Is the UK tax-free lump sum taxed in the US?

The UK tax-free lump sum may or may not be taxed in the US: it depends on the treaty position your adviser takes and on any foreign tax credits you have carried forward. The same withdrawal can produce no US tax, a partly sheltered charge or a full charge.

The lump sum is the clearest example of why pension advice needs both countries in the same room. In the UK the answer is usually simple. In the US it depends on a treaty reading and on credits you may have built up years earlier.

Here is the treaty problem in plain terms. Article 17(2) says a lump sum from a pension scheme in one country, paid to a resident of the other, is taxable only in the country where the scheme is. For a US citizen living in the UK, the saving clause in Article 1(4) lets the US tax its citizens as if the treaty did not exist, and Article 1(5)(a) lists the paragraphs that survive it. Article 17(2) is not on that list. Article 17(1)(b) is, and some advisers argue that it covers the tax-free amount because that amount would be exempt in the UK. You will find both views in practice. An adviser should tell you which one they take and why.

Illustrative example: a US citizen aged 60, resident in Bristol, takes a £100,000 tax-free lump sum from a SIPP in the 2026/27 tax year. The amount is within the £268,275 lump sum allowance, so no UK tax is due. We assume an invented exchange rate of £1 = $1.30, so the lump sum is $130,000, and a flat 24% US rate for simplicity. The client also has $18,000 of unused foreign tax credits carried forward from earlier years of UK salary, in the same category as the lump sum.

US position takenUS tax before creditsCarried-forward credits usedUS tax payable
Exempt under Article 17(1)(b), disclosed on Form 8833$0$0 (credits kept for later years)$0
Taxable, with carried-forward credits applied$31,200$18,000$13,200
Taxable, with no credits available$31,200$0$31,200

The figures are ours and simplified, but the spread is the point: the same £100,000 produces anything from nothing to more than $31,000 of US tax. The Form 1116 instructions let unused foreign tax be carried back one year and forward ten, so the timing of a lump sum against your old credits can matter as much as the treaty reading. A specialist should model the lump sum against your credit history before you ask the provider for it. We look at the treaty reading in more depth in our guide to US tax on a UK pension lump sum.

Contributions: where UK relief and US relief part company

UK pension contributions do not automatically reduce US income. The relief comes from the treaty, and the treaty is narrower than most people expect.

Workplace pensions and Article 18(5)

Article 18(5) of the treaty gives a US citizen resident in the UK a US deduction or exclusion for contributions to a UK pension scheme, and for employer contributions and benefits accrued, where the job is in the UK and the pay is borne by a UK employer. It has limits. The relief cannot exceed what the US would allow for a comparable US plan, and under Article 18(5)(d) it applies only where the US competent authority has agreed that the scheme generally corresponds to a US plan. The treaty documents, including the technical explanation, are on the IRS United Kingdom treaty page. A specialist should confirm that your scheme qualifies before excluding a single contribution.

SIPPs and personal contributions

Article 18(5) is written around employment with a UK employer. Personal contributions outside that, such as a self-employed person paying into a SIPP, generally fall outside its wording, so the UK relief may have no US equivalent. That does not make the SIPP a bad idea, but it changes the arithmetic, and a specialist should show you the US cost of each pound contributed before you commit to a level. Our guide to UK workplace pensions for US citizens covers the employee side in more detail.

Reporting: FBAR, Form 8938 and Form 3520

Reporting is where pension files most often go wrong quietly, year after year. Three US forms can be involved, and each has its own test.

  • FBAR (FinCEN Form 114): required when the combined value of your foreign financial accounts exceeds $10,000 at any time in the calendar year. The IRS FBAR page gives a due date of April 15, with an automatic extension to October 15.
  • Form 8938: for a taxpayer living abroad, the IRS thresholds are more than $200,000 at the end of the year or $300,000 at any time if single, and $400,000 or $600,000 for a joint return. The Form 8938 instructions say to report your interest in a foreign pension plan, not the assets the plan holds.
  • Form 3520: a UK pension can be a foreign trust for US purposes. Revenue Procedure 2020-17 removes Forms 3520 and 3520-A for a tax-favoured foreign retirement trust, but only if it meets every condition, including contributions limited to earned income or to $50,000 a year or $1,000,000 in total.

That last condition deserves a closer look than it usually gets. The UK annual allowance converts to more than $50,000, so a workplace scheme or SIPP relies on the alternative test: contributions limited by a percentage of earned income. Most UK schemes can meet it, but a SIPP that has taken a transfer in, or contributions from someone else, needs checking. A specialist should record why each scheme qualifies, not assume it.

Transfers and the 2027 Inheritance Tax change

Two decisions can be very expensive if they are made in the wrong order: moving a pension across the border, and planning who inherits it.

On transfers, GOV.UK warns that a transfer to an overseas scheme may face a 25% overseas transfer charge unless an exclusion applies, and the receiving scheme must be a qualifying recognised overseas pension scheme. On the US side the question is whether the move is a taxable distribution. Our guide to transferring a UK pension to the US explains why the answer is often to leave the pension where it is.

On inheritance, the UK is bringing most unused pension funds and death benefits into the estate for Inheritance Tax for deaths on or after 6 April 2027. The GOV.UK policy paper says personal representatives, not pension schemes, will be responsible for reporting and paying, and that death-in-service benefits from registered schemes are excluded. For a US/UK family the pension now sits inside two estate tax systems at once, so beneficiary nominations, wills and the US estate position need to be reviewed together.

How to choose tax specialists for US/UK pensions: five tests

Credentials matter, and we cover them in our guide to checking a cross-border adviser's credentials. For pensions, these five practical tests tell you more in a first meeting.

  1. Ask about your lump sum. A capable adviser will name Article 17(2), the saving clause and Article 17(1)(b) without prompting, say which position they would take for you and explain whether it needs Form 8833.
  2. Ask how your contributions are treated in the US. Listen for Article 18(5), the employer test and the cap at US limits. "UK pensions are tax-free in the US" is not an answer.
  3. Ask whether your schemes meet Revenue Procedure 2020-17. The adviser should check each scheme against the conditions and put the conclusion in writing.
  4. Ask for a two-country projection before any withdrawal. The projection should show UK tax, US tax and foreign tax credits by year, including any carryforwards.
  5. Ask who else is involved. Transfers and drawdown usually need a UK regulated financial adviser as well. A good tax adviser will want to speak to them before you sign anything.

If an adviser answers the first two in general terms only, keep looking. You can see how we approach these files on our US/UK pensions service page and, for people already drawing income, on our page for US/UK retirees.

What to bring to a first pension review

A first review goes faster, and costs less, when the facts are on the table. Bring the latest annual statement for every pension in both countries, any transfer paperwork, your last three US and UK returns (including any FBARs and Forms 8938, 8833 or 3520), and your payslips showing pension deductions. Add your employer's scheme booklet if you have one, because the scheme rules decide several of the US answers.

US/UK Cross Border Tax is US CPAs and UK tax advisers working as one team, with offices in London, Manchester, New York and San Francisco. If a pension decision is coming up in the next year, book a pension review with us before you contact the provider, so the cost under both systems is known before anything is paid out.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a cross-border specialist if I only have a UK workplace pension?

Often you need one review rather than a large annual engagement. A UK workplace pension still raises US questions every year: whether the contributions are excluded under Article 18(5) of the treaty, how the account is reported on the FBAR and Form 8938, and whether Form 3520 applies. Once those positions are set and documented, a single workplace pension is usually simple to carry forward on each return.

Is the UK 25% tax-free lump sum taxable in the US?

There is no settled answer that suits every case. Article 17(2) of the US-UK treaty gives the UK the right to tax a lump sum from a UK scheme, but the saving clause lets the US tax its own citizens, and that paragraph is not on the list of exceptions. Some advisers rely on Article 17(1)(b) instead to treat the amount as exempt. The position you take should be explained and, where relevant, disclosed on Form 8833.

Can a 401(k) be transferred to a UK pension, or a SIPP to a US plan?

Moving money between the two systems is rarely simple. A transfer out of a UK registered pension scheme to an overseas scheme generally has to go to a qualifying recognised overseas pension scheme, and GOV.UK says a 25% overseas transfer charge can apply unless an exclusion fits. A 401(k) withdrawal paid into a UK pension is treated as a taxable distribution in the US. Get both calculations before you sign any transfer form.

What does a tax specialist for US/UK pensions charge?

Fees depend on what is being decided rather than on the number of pots. A once-off review of existing pensions and reporting positions usually costs less than planning a drawdown or transfer, which needs projections under both tax systems. Ask for a written scope that lists each pension, each decision and each form, and a fixed fee for that scope. Our guide to adviser fees explains the fee models you are likely to see.

Does my UK pension need to be on my FBAR?

In most cases, yes. The FBAR, FinCEN Form 114, is required when the combined value of your foreign financial accounts exceeds $10,000 at any time in the calendar year, and UK pension accounts are commonly treated as reportable foreign accounts. Form 8938 is a separate test: its instructions tell you to report your interest in a foreign pension plan, not the investments inside it. Revenue Procedure 2020-17 does not remove either form.

Should a pension specialist also be a financial adviser?

Not necessarily, and it is often better if the roles are separate. A UK regulated financial adviser recommends investments and products, while a cross-border tax adviser works out how each choice is taxed in both countries. The two should talk before any transfer or drawdown. Be cautious if one firm sells the product and also signs off the tax position on it without showing the calculation.

This article is general information, not personal tax advice. Thresholds, rates and deadlines change; confirm current figures on the official sources above and speak to a qualified US/UK tax adviser about your own circumstances.

Written by the US/UK Cross Border Tax team — US CPAs and UK tax advisers, London · Manchester · New York · San Francisco. About us. Last reviewed: November 6, 2026.

Plan your pension decision under both tax systems

Tell us which pensions you hold and what you are planning, and our US CPAs and UK tax advisers will set out the tax cost on each side before you contribute, transfer or draw.

Get a Fee Quote
Contact US/UK Cross Border Tax

Two Tax Systems, One Team

London Headquarters

4 Crown Place
London EC2A 4BT
United Kingdom

Manchester

CORE
Brown St, Manchester M2 1DH
United Kingdom

San Francisco

600 California St
San Francisco, CA 94108
United States

New York

33 Irving Pl
New York, NY 10003
United States

Start a Conversation