UK Tax Codes for Americans: Why Yours Might Be Wrong and How to Fix It
The starter checklist answers, coded-out US income and missing allowance tapers that put Americans on the wrong UK tax code, how to correct it with HMRC, and what the correction does to your US return.

If your UK tax code is wrong and you are an American in Britain, the cause is usually one of three things: a starter checklist answer given on arrival, US income HMRC has estimated into the code, or a change HMRC has not been told about. You fix it with HMRC directly, online or in the HMRC app, and then check what the correction does to your US return.
A tax code is an instruction from HMRC to your employer or pension payer. It says how much of your pay is tax-free and which rates to use. It is not a tax bill, and it is not final: it is HMRC's best estimate of your year, built from whatever information it has. For someone who has lived in the UK all their life with one job, that estimate is usually right. For an American who arrived mid-year, gets income from the US, or files Self Assessment, it is wrong more often than people realise.
This guide is written for that second group. It covers where a wrong code comes from, how to read the code you have, how to get it corrected and, because you also file with the IRS, how the refund or extra tax lands on the US side.
What does a UK tax code actually tell your employer?
A UK tax code tells payroll your tax-free allowance and how to tax the rest. GOV.UK explains that the numbers show how much tax-free income you get, and that 1257L is the code currently used for most people with one job or pension. For 2026/27, the tax year from 6 April 2026 to 5 April 2027, the standard Personal Allowance is £12,570; drop the last digit and add a letter and you have 1257L.
The letters carry the rest of the message. These are the ones Americans in the UK see most, taken from HMRC's employer guide to what the letters mean:
| Code you see | What payroll does | When it is usually right | When it is often wrong for an American |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1257L | Gives the standard allowance across the year, cumulatively | One UK job, no untaxed income | Income above £100,000, or US income HMRC has not been told about |
| 1257L M1 or W1 | Gives the allowance one month or week at a time, ignoring earlier pay | Briefly, after starting a job without a P45 | Still on payslips months after you arrived |
| BR | Taxes everything at 20%, no allowance | A genuine second UK job or pension | Your only UK job, because statement C was ticked for a US pension |
| 0T | No allowance at all | Allowance already used, or no details given | Starter checklist never returned to HR |
| A lower number, such as 857L | Gives a smaller allowance to collect tax on other income | Real untaxed income such as foreign dividends | The US income has stopped but the estimate remains |
| K followed by a number | Adds an amount to taxable pay | Untaxed income or benefits exceed the allowance | Prior-year US income rolled forward on a guess |
| S or C prefix | Uses Scottish or Welsh rates | Your main home is in Scotland or Wales | You moved within the UK and HMRC has the old address |
One technical point helps when reading payslips. HMRC tells employers that for a K code they multiply the number in the tax code by 10 to find the amount added to taxable income, and GOV.UK's employee guide says payroll cannot take more than half of your pre-tax pay using a K code. The same "times 10" logic works roughly in reverse for ordinary codes: 857L means about £8,570 of tax-free pay instead of £12,570.
Why is my UK tax code wrong? The American-specific causes
A UK tax code is usually wrong for an American because HMRC set it with incomplete information about your arrival, your US income or your total earnings. Generic tax code guides cover job changes and company cars. These are the causes we see that are specific to people with US ties.
1. The starter checklist answer on arrival
Most Americans start their first UK job without a P45, because a P45 only comes from a UK employer. The employer then uses the HMRC starter checklist. HMRC's tool for employers, work out your new employee's tax code, maps the answers like this for 2026/27:
- Statement A (first job since 6 April, no taxable benefits or pension): code 1257L.
- Statement B (only job now, but another job or certain benefits since 6 April): 1257L on a Week 1/Month 1 basis.
- Statement C (another job, or a State, workplace or private pension): code BR.
- No declaration: 0T on a Week 1/Month 1 basis.
Two traps follow. First, the standard starter checklist asks whether you receive payments from a State, workplace or private pension. An American who draws US Social Security or a US pension often answers yes and lands on BR for their only UK salary, losing the whole allowance on that job. The question is built around pensions paid through UK payroll. US pension income is still relevant to your UK tax (our guide to UK tax on US Social Security explains why it is generally taxable here), but the way to deal with it is to tell HMRC, not to remove your allowance from your salary.
Second, people sent over by a US employer are often handed the separate starter checklist for employees seconded to work in the UK, whose statements ask whether you intend to live in the UK for 183 days or more, less than 183 days, or to live abroad while working both inside and outside the UK. Pick the statement that matches your real plans. If the plan changes, the code may need to change too.
2. US income HMRC has estimated into your code
Once you file a Self Assessment return that shows US dividends, interest or rent, HMRC can use the next year's tax code to collect tax on similar income during the year. The guidance on K codes lists savings interest above the Personal Savings Allowance among the untaxed income that can be coded out. The estimate is usually based on the last return HMRC has. If you sold a US brokerage account, sold a US rental or simply had a one-off year, the code keeps collecting tax on income you no longer have.
3. Income over £100,000 the code does not know about
GOV.UK says the Personal Allowance goes down by £1 for every £2 that adjusted net income is above £100,000, reaching nil at £125,140. A code of 1257L assumes you keep all of it. If US-side income, a UK bonus or vesting RSUs push you over £100,000, the code is too generous and you underpay in-year. Our guide to UK tax on RSUs for US employees covers how equity pay shows up in payroll.
4. A US employer with UK payroll, plus a second job
BR is correct for a genuine second job. It is wrong when the "first job" has ended and the BR job is now your only one, or when your allowance is sitting on a job that pays less than £12,570. HMRC can move the allowance between employments, but only if you tell it.
How to check whether your tax code is right
GOV.UK lists four places to find your tax code: the Check your Income Tax online service, the HMRC app, your payslip, and any Tax Code Notice letter. Online, you can also see the employment and estimated income HMRC has used to build the code. That breakdown is where American-specific errors show up: a line for "untaxed interest" or "foreign income" you no longer receive, a pension that is not paid through PAYE, or an allowance allocated to the wrong job.
Use this checklist whenever a new code arrives:
- Is the letter L, M or N on your main job? If it is BR, 0T or D0 on your only job, something is wrong.
- Is there an M1, W1 or X suffix? Fine for your first weeks; a problem after two or three payslips.
- Does the number match £12,570 less anything HMRC is deducting? Read each deduction line in the online breakdown.
- Is every deduction still true for this tax year? Compare coded-out US income with what you actually expect to receive.
- Will your total income pass £100,000? If so, the allowance should be tapered.
- Is the S or C prefix right for where your main home is?
How to fix a wrong UK tax code, step by step
You fix a wrong UK tax code by updating your details with HMRC; your employer cannot change it for you. GOV.UK's page on how to update your tax code sets out the route:
- Wait the right amount of time if you are new. If you have just started a job, HMRC asks you to wait 35 days for your income details to arrive before contacting it. The emergency tax code guidance gives the same 35-day window.
- Sign in to Check your Income Tax or the HMRC app. Correct the employment details, estimated income, benefits or pensions shown. You will need to sign in or create an HMRC online account first.
- Update the estimate of other income. This is where you remove US dividends, interest or rent you no longer receive, or add US pension income HMRC does not know about.
- Keep a note of what you changed and when. You will want it when reconciling the year, and when your US preparer asks why UK tax withheld dropped in one month.
- Watch for the new code. HMRC says it will tell you and your employer the new code within 15 working days. It should appear on the next or following monthly payslip, or by the third weekly payslip.
- Phone or write if you cannot use the online service. HMRC's income tax helpline for individuals and employees is the fallback, and an authorised agent can use the PAYE coding notice query form for a client.
If your circumstances are more tangled than one wrong line, for instance several years of US income, a Self Assessment balance and a code you cannot reconcile, our team handles this as part of help for Americans whose UK tax code is wrong alongside the US return.
What happens to the tax you overpaid or underpaid?
Overpaid tax from a wrong code is normally refunded through your pay. GOV.UK says HMRC will ask your employer or pension provider to refund the difference in your pay once the new code is used. Underpaid tax is usually collected by adjusting the code over one or more tax years, if possible.
After the year ends HMRC reconciles PAYE. GOV.UK explains that a tax calculation letter, known as a P800, goes out between June and March of the following tax year if you paid too much or too little, and that a Simple Assessment letter may come instead where you owe more than £3,000 or tax that cannot be collected through your income. If you file Self Assessment, a balance under £3,000 can be collected through your tax code when you already pay through PAYE and file online by 30 December (or on paper by 31 October). That coded-out balance then appears in next year's code, which is another reason an American's code can look wrong when it is not. For whether you need a return at all, see do I need to file Self Assessment in the UK, and for return support, our UK Self Assessment service.
Worked example: coded-out US dividends that stopped
Illustrative example: an American living in London earns a £60,000 UK salary, paid monthly. Their 2025/26 Self Assessment return showed about £4,000 of US dividends and interest. HMRC builds a 2026/27 code of 857L, taking £4,000 off the £12,570 allowance to collect tax on that income through payroll. In March 2026 they had sold the US holdings and moved the cash into a UK account, so no US dividends arrive in 2026/27. All figures are invented and rounded, and ignore National Insurance.
| Step | Figure | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Allowance lost to the estimate | £4,000 | 857L instead of 1257L |
| Extra tax over a full year at their 40% marginal rate | £1,600 | Salary is above the £50,270 higher-rate threshold |
| Extra tax per month | about £133 | £1,600 ÷ 12 |
| Overpaid April to September, before the fix | about £800 | Six months × £133 |
| Refund on the October payslip | about £800 | Cumulative 1257L code gives back the allowance from 6 April |
On the UK side, the fix is a five-minute update to estimated income. On the US side, the employee now has UK tax withheld that rose and then fell within calendar 2026. The UK income tax that counts for the US foreign tax credit is what was actually paid for the year, so the October refund reduces the 2026 figure. Had the fix come after 31 December, with the refund landing in January 2027, the 2026 credit would have been claimed on tax later refunded. That is the situation the next section covers.
How a corrected UK tax code affects your US return
A corrected UK tax code changes how much UK income tax you paid in each calendar year, and the US foreign tax credit follows the tax actually paid. IRS Publication 514 says that if you use the cash method, you can claim the credit only in the year in which you pay the tax, and it lists a refund of foreign taxes as one of the events that require a foreign tax redetermination. Where the redetermination changes your US tax, Publication 514 says you generally file Form 1040-X with a revised Form 1116; where it does not, you attach Schedule C (Form 1116) to the return for the year it happens.
In practice that means three things for Americans fixing a code:
- Fix early in the year. A refund paid within the same calendar year reduces the UK tax paid for that year before you file, so there is usually nothing to redetermine later.
- Build the US figure from payslips, not the P60. Our guide to the P60 and your US tax return shows how to total UK tax by pay date, so mid-year refunds are captured in the right month.
- Tell your US preparer about P800 refunds and coded-out balances. A P800 refund for 2025/26 received in 2026 relates to tax that may already sit on your 2025 Form 1116. Whether you use the credit or the exclusion also matters; see FEIE vs foreign tax credit for UK residents.
What people get wrong about UK tax codes
- Asking HR to change the code. HR can only apply the code HMRC sends; the request has to go to HMRC.
- Treating M1 as permanent. An emergency basis should clear within weeks. If it is still there in month three, update your details.
- Leaving last year's US income in the estimate. HMRC will keep collecting on it until you change it.
- Ignoring the £100,000 taper. A 1257L code on a £115,000 income leads to an underpayment letter later.
- Assuming a code change is only a UK matter. Every refund or extra deduction moves the UK tax paid figure on your US return.
Getting both sides right
A wrong UK tax code is rarely expensive if it is caught within a few months, and it is almost always fixable online. The cost comes when it runs for a year or more, triggers a P800 or Simple Assessment, and then has to be unpicked on a US return already filed. US/UK Cross Border Tax — US CPAs and UK tax advisers working as one team; London, Manchester, New York, San Francisco — checks the code as part of preparing both returns, so the UK figure and the US credit tell the same story. If your code looks wrong now, get in touch and send us your latest Tax Code Notice.
Frequently asked questions
Why is my UK tax code wrong when I just moved from the US?
Most new arrivals have no P45, so the employer sets the first code from the starter checklist. Statement A gives 1257L, statement B gives 1257L on a Week 1/Month 1 basis, statement C gives BR and no answer at all gives 0T Week 1/Month 1. HMRC then replaces that code once it has your details, which GOV.UK says can take up to 35 days from your start date.
Should I tick statement C if I receive US Social Security or a US pension?
Statement C tells the employer to use code BR, which gives no tax-free allowance on that job. The checklist question is designed around pensions paid through UK payroll. A US pension or US Social Security paid from America does not come through PAYE, so ticking C can leave you overtaxed on your salary. Tell HMRC about the US income instead and let it decide how to collect the tax.
Can HMRC put my US dividends or interest into my UK tax code?
Yes. HMRC can reduce your tax code to collect tax on income that is not taxed at source, including foreign savings and dividends reported on an earlier Self Assessment return. If the untaxed income is larger than your Personal Allowance you get a K code, and GOV.UK says employers cannot take more than half of your pre-tax pay using a K code.
How long does it take HMRC to correct a wrong tax code?
After you update your details in the Check your Income Tax service or the HMRC app, HMRC says it will tell you and your employer the new code within 15 working days. Monthly-paid employees usually see the new code on the next or following payslip, and weekly-paid employees by the third payslip. Any overpaid tax is normally refunded through pay once the new code is used.
Does a UK tax refund through payroll affect my US tax return?
It can. On the US return you claim credit for UK income tax actually paid. If a corrected code refunds tax in the same calendar year, the credit uses the net figure. If the refund arrives in a later year for tax you already credited, IRS Publication 514 treats it as a foreign tax redetermination, which may need an amended return with a revised Form 1116.
What does an M1 or W1 at the end of my tax code mean?
M1 (Month 1) and W1 (Week 1) are emergency bases. Payroll works out tax using only the pay in that month or week, ignoring earlier months of the tax year. That stops refunds of tax overpaid before you joined, so a new arrival on 1257L M1 usually pays more than necessary until HMRC issues a normal cumulative code.
Can my employer change my tax code for me?
No. The employer must use the code HMRC sends. The employer chooses the starting code for a new employee from the P45 or starter checklist, but after that only HMRC can change it. You update your details with HMRC online or through the HMRC app, and an authorised agent can use the PAYE coding notice query form for a client.
Official sources
- GOV.UK — Tax codes: what your tax code means
- GOV.UK — Emergency tax codes
- GOV.UK — If you have a K in your tax code
- GOV.UK — How to update your tax code
- GOV.UK — If you've paid too much or too little tax
- GOV.UK — Work out your new employee's tax code
- GOV.UK — Understanding your employees' tax codes
- GOV.UK — Starter checklist (PDF)
- GOV.UK — Starter checklist for employees seconded to the UK (PDF)
- GOV.UK — Income Tax rates and Personal Allowances
- GOV.UK — Tax overpayments and underpayments
- GOV.UK — Pay your Self Assessment bill through your tax code
- IRS — Publication 514, Foreign Tax Credit for Individuals
This article is general information, not personal tax advice. Thresholds, rates and deadlines change; confirm current figures on the official sources above and speak to a qualified US/UK tax adviser about your own circumstances.
Written by the US/UK Cross Border Tax team — US CPAs and UK tax advisers, London · Manchester · New York · San Francisco. About us. Last reviewed: November 4, 2026.
Tax code looks wrong? Send us the notice
Our US CPAs and UK tax advisers check your UK tax code against your real income, correct it with HMRC and carry any refund through to your US foreign tax credit.
Get a Fee QuoteTwo Tax Systems, One Team
Email Us
hello@usukcrossbordertax.comLondon Headquarters
4 Crown Place
London EC2A 4BT
United Kingdom
Manchester
CORE
Brown St, Manchester M2 1DH
United Kingdom
San Francisco
600 California St
San Francisco, CA 94108
United States
New York
33 Irving Pl
New York, NY 10003
United States