UK Tax on US LLC Income: Anson, the New Credit and What to Do Before 2028
On 28 October 2026 the government dropped its plan to look through US LLCs and chose a foreign tax credit instead, with claims from early 2028. Here is what that means for distributions you take, or hold back, in the meantime.

UK tax on US LLC income normally falls on distributions, at dividend rates, while the US taxes the underlying profit as it arises, and neither country credits the other. On 28 October 2026 the government said it will fix this with an elective credit, claimable from early 2028. Until then the double charge stands.
Most guidance on this subject was written around the June 2026 consultation, which proposed looking through LLCs. That proposal has gone. The live question for a UK-resident member is now a practical one: what do you do with distributions in the 15 or so months before the credit can be claimed, when nobody yet knows how it will treat them? This article prices that decision.
Why does UK tax on a US LLC produce such high rates?
UK tax on a US LLC runs high because the two countries tax different things. The IRS treats a multi-member LLC as a partnership and a single-member LLC as disregarded by default, so the member pays US tax on the profit each year, whether or not cash comes out.
HMRC starts from the opposite place. Its entity classification list at INTM180030 shows the US LLC as opaque, and INTM180050 says individual members are generally taxed only on distributions, at the dividend rate. Where the LLC is a partnership or disregarded for US purposes, that page says there is no double tax relief for the member's US tax.
So one slice of profit gets charged twice, on two different legal footings, and the ordinary double taxation relief rules do not connect them. The government's summary of responses records effective rates commonly reported at 55% to 75%, with some above 80% once state and local taxes are counted. Those are respondents' figures, not HMRC's own calculations.
The US side rarely helps. The same summary records that attempts to get US relief for UK tax on LLC distributions mostly failed, partly because the US has primary taxing rights over income from a US business under Article 7 of the treaty. A US citizen should not assume a Form 1116 credit will mop up the UK charge.
What did the Anson case decide, and does it still help?
Anson v HMRC decided that one UK resident could claim relief for US tax on his share of a Delaware LLC's profits. The Supreme Court's press summary explains that the First-tier Tribunal had found, under the Delaware Act and that LLC's agreement, that profits belonged to the members as they arose. The income taxed in the two countries was therefore the same income.
HMRC has confined the result ever since. Brief 15 (2015) calls the decision "specific to the facts found in the case" and says individual claims are considered case by case. INTM180050 goes further: HMRC disagrees with the tribunal's finding, does not treat capital account allocations as creating a liability to the member, and warns of enquiries and discovery assessments against members who self-assess on an Anson basis.
An Anson position is therefore still arguable but contested. It rests on your operating agreement, not on the case name. The government's own reason for legislating, set out in the June 2026 consultation, is that members who try to apply Anson to their own LLCs risk disputes.
What changed on 28 October 2026?
The government dropped look-through treatment for US LLCs and chose a credit. The outcome document says transparency would have needed exclusions for single-member and UK-run entities, and would have been unworkable for many minority and indirect investors. Credit relief is described as more accessible to all categories of investor.
The design so far, all of it from the same outcome document:
- Named entities. Legislation will specify eligible entities, including US LLCs, US S corporations, Jersey LLCs and French SCIs, and treat them as opaque for an individual member.
- Dividend rates stay. Distributions to individual members are charged at dividend rates of Income Tax.
- Elective credit. A member can elect credit for eligible foreign taxes paid personally on the entity's profits, income and gains. Federal, state and local taxes all count.
- Average rate, not tracing. The credit uses the member's average rate of foreign tax under mechanical rules, so individual dollars are not followed through.
- Timing. A technical consultation comes first, then a future Finance Bill, with claims possible from early 2028.
Three questions are expressly left open: how to compute the average rate across mixed income, how to handle timing gaps between the US charge and the UK distribution, and how to deal with the gap between dividend rates and other rates. As of this article's date we could not find the technical consultation on GOV.UK. Prior periods and live disputes get one sentence: the government is "considering practical options".
What does UK tax on a US LLC cost under each treatment?
The figures below use one set of facts so the four routes can be compared directly. The dividend rate is the 39.35% additional rate for 2026/27 and the income rate is the 45% additional rate.
Illustrative example: a UK-resident member has a share of US LLC trading profit equal to £100,000, carried on wholly in the US, and all of it is distributed in the year. We assume a 30% average US tax rate, covering federal and state, which is a round figure chosen for the example and not a rate you should expect. Other UK income already uses the allowances and lower bands. National Insurance, currency movements and US self-employment tax are ignored.
| Treatment | US tax | UK tax | Total tax | Kept |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HMRC's opaque view, today: dividend tax, no credit | £30,000 | £39,350 | £69,350 | £30,650 |
| Anson-basis return: 45% on the profit share, less a £30,000 credit (contested) | £30,000 | £15,000 | £45,000 | £55,000 |
| FIG regime claimed, if eligible (allowances lost) | £30,000 | £0 | £30,000 | £70,000 |
| Planned credit from 2028, simplest reading: £39,350 less £30,000 | £30,000 | £9,350 | £39,350 | £60,650 |
The last row is our own arithmetic on a design that has no draft legislation behind it. The outcome document says only that relief should reduce the effective rate to a reasonable level, often broadly comparable to investing through a UK limited company. Treat that row as a direction of travel.
The retention trap
The obvious response is to leave profits in the LLC until the credit arrives. The difficulty is the US bill, which falls due every year on profit you have not taken out. On the facts above, the member owes £30,000 of US tax. If the only cash is inside the LLC, and the distribution is taxed at 39.35%, they must draw £49,464 to have £30,000 left after UK tax (£30,000 ÷ 0.6065).
That produces £19,464 of UK dividend tax with no credit, just to pay the US tax on money that stayed in the business. Total tax on the £100,000 of profit is already £49,464, and the remaining £50,536 still carries a UK charge when it eventually comes out. Retention narrows the double charge. It does not remove it unless the member has other cash to meet the US bill.
Should you distribute now or wait for the 2028 credit?
The answer depends on where you sit, so we built this table to sort members quickly. It is a starting point for a conversation with an adviser, not a substitute for one, and every "wait" carries the risk that the final rules differ.
| Your position | Leaning | Why, and what to check |
|---|---|---|
| Inside your first 4 FIG years | Distribute while relieved | A distribution in a FIG year can escape UK tax. Holding profit past your fourth year moves it into the charge. Check the allowance loss is worth it. |
| FIG window ends before 2028 | Plan the final FIG year carefully | Your last relieved year may come before any credit exists, so a gap year or two at full dividend rates is possible. |
| Past FIG, with other cash for US tax | Consider deferring | Deferral costs you little if the LLC does not need to pay out, but relief for profit taxed before the start date is unconfirmed. |
| Past FIG, LLC funds your US tax | Take the minimum | Size the distribution to the US bill plus UK tax on it, using the gross-up above, and keep the rest in the business only if there is a commercial reason. |
| Minority member, no say on payouts | Model the cash | You may be taxed in the US without any distribution, or receive one you cannot refuse. Ask the manager about tax distribution clauses. |
| Already filing on an Anson basis | Review, do not switch blindly | Changing basis between years can leave profit taxed twice or not at all, and the government is still considering live disputes. |
The FIG rows rely on GOV.UK's guidance on the 4-year regime, which requires at least 10 prior years of non-UK residence and costs you the tax-free income tax and capital gains allowances in a year you claim. Our guide to the end of non-dom status for Americans covers how the wider regime works.
Why might the credit not fix a UK-run LLC?
A founder who runs a US LLC from Britain has a separate problem that the credit does not address: the LLC itself may be a UK tax resident company. HMRC's INTM120060 says a company formed abroad is UK resident if central management and control is here, that the test is primarily one of fact, and that control exercised by an individual shareholder who has taken over management can count.
The October 2026 outcome is explicit that the entity "would remain potentially chargeable to Corporation Tax according to the usual rules". For a single-member LLC whose only decision-maker lives in Manchester, that is a live risk today. It would also move the facts well away from the simple table above, because profit earned by work done in the UK is unlikely to sit comfortably as US business income. The summary of responses records working founders raising exactly this concern. Our founders page sets out how we approach those structures.
Restructuring deserves equal care. Respondents listed conversion and a US check-the-box election on Form 8832 among their mitigations, and warned of collateral damage. On the published design the credit covers foreign tax paid by the member personally, so tax paid by an LLC that has elected corporate status looks unlikely to qualify. That election is the sort of step to model against the coming rules rather than make in a hurry.
A checklist for US LLC members before early 2028
- Pull the operating agreement. Read the clauses on allocations, distributions and capital accounts. INTM180040 makes the governing documents and foreign law central to classification, and says the entity's foreign tax treatment is not relevant to that step.
- Write down who decides what, and where. Record where strategic decisions are actually taken. This is your evidence on central management and control.
- Fix your FIG dates. Work out the first and last tax years you can claim, then map planned distributions against them.
- Start a year-by-year ledger. For each US tax year, record your allocated profit and the federal, state and local tax you paid personally. For each UK tax year, record each distribution, its date and its sterling value. A credit built on average foreign tax rates will need this, and it is much harder to rebuild later.
- Choose and document your filing position. If you take an Anson position, set it out plainly on your Self Assessment return and in the white space. Distributions treated as foreign dividends belong in the foreign pages covered in our SA106 guide.
- Hold off irreversible restructuring. Do not convert or elect until you have modelled the outcome against the technical consultation.
- Watch for the technical consultation. The outcome document invites people who want to join roundtables to write to HMRC's entity classification mailbox, and it is the place the timing rules will first appear.
What people get wrong about US LLCs and UK tax
- "My LLC is ignored by the IRS, so HMRC ignores it too." The two classifications are independent. INTM180040 says tax treatment abroad is not relevant when HMRC reaches its view.
- "The new law has fixed this." Nothing has been enacted. HMRC's view and the double charge continue until a Finance Bill says otherwise.
- "The reform will tax me on profits as they arise." That was the June proposal. The October outcome keeps tax on distributions at dividend rates, which also means a loss inside the LLC gets no new look-through relief under this design.
- "Only Delaware LLCs are affected." INTM180050 says HMRC understands other states' LLC laws to be substantially the same. S corporations, Jersey LLCs and French SCIs are also named in the plan.
- "This only matters to Americans." The consultation notes that a UK-resident member need not be a US citizen, resident or green card holder. A British investor in a US fund vehicle can be caught too.
How we help members of US LLCs
US/UK Cross Border Tax is US CPAs and UK tax advisers working as one team, with offices in London, Manchester, New York and San Francisco. For a US LLC member, that means the same people look at the Form 1040 or nonresident return, the UK return and the operating agreement together. Our international tax services cover classification reviews, distribution modelling and the record-keeping the credit is likely to demand. For a US citizen owner, our note on the treaty saving clause explains why the treaty alone rarely settles the matter. To talk through your own LLC, contact us with the operating agreement and your last two years of returns to hand.
This article reflects published sources as of 1 November 2026, and the credit's rules remain subject to consultation and legislation.
Frequently asked questions
Is a US LLC transparent or opaque for UK tax?
HMRC lists the US LLC as opaque in its International Manual at INTM180030, and INTM180050 says members of Delaware LLCs generally become entitled to profits only when a distribution is made. That is a general view, not a ruling on your entity. INTM180040 says the answer can turn on the governing documents and the foreign law, and a member wanting certainty can ask HMRC about a specific LLC.
Can I still rely on the Anson case on my UK tax return?
You can file on that basis, but expect a challenge. The Supreme Court allowed Mr Anson's relief because of findings about his own Delaware LLC agreement. HMRC says the decision is specific to those facts, considers individual claims case by case, and states in INTM180050 that it may open enquiries or make discovery assessments where members self-assess as if profits belong to them. Take advice first and disclose the position clearly.
When does the new UK credit for US LLC members start?
The government says claims for the new credit will be possible from early 2028. It has promised a technical consultation first, followed by legislation in a future Finance Bill, so the rules could still move. The published design is elective and covers federal, state and local foreign taxes paid personally by the member. Until it is law, a UK-resident member's distributions stay taxable at dividend rates with no credit for the US tax.
Will the credit apply to distributions I take before 2028?
That is unanswered. The October 2026 outcome document says the government understands the significance of prior periods and ongoing disputes and is considering practical options, but it commits to nothing. Timing mismatches between US tax and UK distributions are on the list for the technical consultation. Plan on the footing that a distribution taken now gets no credit, and treat any later relief as a bonus.
Does the 4-year FIG regime cover US LLC distributions?
It can. The GOV.UK guidance on the 4-year foreign income and gains regime lists dividends from non-UK resident companies as qualifying income, and the consultation responses name FIG as a mitigation members use. Two conditions matter: you must be within your first 4 years of UK residence after at least 10 years abroad, and the LLC must not itself be UK resident. Claiming costs you the tax-free income tax and capital gains allowances.
Could my US LLC become a UK tax resident company?
Yes. A company formed outside the UK is UK resident if its central management and control is here, and HMRC's INTM120060 says that test is a question of fact about where the highest-level decisions are really taken. A UK-resident sole member who runs a US LLC from a home office in Britain is the obvious risk. The October 2026 outcome says an entity stays potentially chargeable to Corporation Tax under the usual rules.
Official sources
- GOV.UK — UK resident individual members of LLCs and other reverse hybrids: summary of responses (28 October 2026)
- GOV.UK — Consultation on reform to taxation of UK-resident members of US LLCs (June 2026)
- HMRC International Manual — INTM180050: US LLCs and Anson
- HMRC International Manual — INTM180030: entity classification list
- HMRC International Manual — INTM180040: how a definitive view is reached
- HMRC International Manual — INTM120060: central management and control
- HMRC — Revenue and Customs Brief 15 (2015): response to Anson
- UK Supreme Court — Anson v HMRC [2015] UKSC 44, press summary
- GOV.UK — Tax on dividends
- GOV.UK — Income Tax rates and Personal Allowances
- GOV.UK — Check if you can claim the 4-year foreign income and gains regime
- IRS — Limited liability company (LLC)
This article is general information, not personal tax advice. Thresholds, rates and deadlines change; confirm current figures on the official sources above and speak to a qualified US/UK tax adviser about your own circumstances.
Written by the US/UK Cross Border Tax team — US CPAs and UK tax advisers, London · Manchester · New York · San Francisco. About us. Last reviewed: November 1, 2026.
Own part of a US LLC and live in the UK?
Our US CPAs and UK tax advisers can review your operating agreement, price your distribution options and set up the records the 2028 credit is likely to need.
Get a Fee QuoteTwo Tax Systems, One Team
Email Us
hello@usukcrossbordertax.comLondon Headquarters
4 Crown Place
London EC2A 4BT
United Kingdom
Manchester
CORE
Brown St, Manchester M2 1DH
United Kingdom
San Francisco
600 California St
San Francisco, CA 94108
United States
New York
33 Irving Pl
New York, NY 10003
United States