Skip to content
Home/Blog/Choosing an Adviser
Choosing an Adviser

US UK Tax Accountants Fees: Fixed Fee, Hourly or Retainer, and Which Fits Your Work

How firms that prepare both US and UK returns actually price the job, why one client often sees three different pricing models in the same year, and a worked example showing when a fixed fee beats an hourly estimate and when it does not.

Updated:November 4, 2026
Reading Time:11 min read
Empty consulting room with a walnut desk, two papers and a pen, where US UK tax accountants agree fees with clients
A short scoping meeting before work starts is where US UK tax accountants fees are set as fixed, capped or hourly.

US UK tax accountants fees are rarely one price. Most firms charge a fixed fee for the annual US and UK returns, bill advice and tax-authority letters by the hour or against a cap, and quote catch-up filings as a separate project. Knowing which model applies to which piece of work is how you compare quotes fairly and avoid surprise invoices in October.

This guide looks at pricing structure, not price lists. There is no official survey of cross-border fees, and any single figure you read online is one firm's tariff. If you want to know what drives the size of the bill (funds, states, companies, catch-up years), our companion guide on how much a cross border tax accountant costs covers those drivers one by one. Here the question is narrower and more practical: how is the fee built, and which model should you accept for each type of work?

How do US UK tax accountants set their fees?

US UK tax accountants set fees by matching the pricing model to how predictable the work is. Recurring returns with a known scope suit a fixed fee; open-ended work, such as answering an IRS notice or planning a move, suits hourly billing or a capped estimate; and one-off projects, such as several years of late filings, are quoted as a single project fee.

The IRS's own rules for practitioners recognise the same building blocks. Circular 230, the Treasury regulation that governs practice before the IRS, lets a practitioner publish fee information in four forms: fixed fees for specific routine services, hourly rates, a range of fees for particular services, and the fee for an initial consultation (Circular 230, §10.30(b)). A practitioner who publishes those rates may not charge more than them for at least 30 calendar days after the last date the schedule was published.

Most cross-border clients end up with more than one of these at once. A typical year for an American living in London might include a fixed fee for the returns, a few hours of advice before selling shares, and an hourly bill to answer an HMRC letter. Each is reasonable on its own; trouble starts when a client assumes the fixed fee covers all three.

The four pricing models, side by side

The table below sets out how each model works on cross-border engagements and where each one goes wrong. It reflects how engagements are commonly structured, not any single firm's terms.

ModelHow it worksBest suited toWhere it goes wrong
Fixed feeOne agreed price for a defined list of returns and formsAnnual US Form 1040, UK Self Assessment return and FBAR once your facts are stableThe scope list is vague, so new items are billed as extras
HourlyTime recorded and billed at an agreed rate per personAdvice, tax-authority correspondence, unusual one-off transactionsNo estimate or cap, so the final bill is unknown until it arrives
Capped hourlyHourly billing with an agreed ceiling; going over needs your approvalA first-year engagement where the firm has not yet seen your recordsThe cap is set low and the work stops halfway pending approval
RetainerA regular payment for an agreed level of access and workClients with frequent decisions: founders, equity-paid employees, people mid-relocationPaying monthly for advice you never use
Project feeOne price for a defined multi-year piece of workCatch-up filings, a streamlined submission, a citizenship renunciation yearHidden assumptions about how many years, accounts or funds are involved

A useful rule: the more you can describe the work in advance, the more of it should be on a fixed fee. The less you can describe, the more you want an estimate with a cap than an open hourly rate.

Fixed fee vs hourly for US UK tax accountants: which is better?

For the recurring US and UK returns, a fixed fee is usually better, because you know the cost before the work starts and the firm carries the risk of the job taking longer than planned. Hourly billing is better for work nobody can scope in advance, provided it comes with a written estimate and a cap.

The exception is the first year. A firm that has never seen your records cannot price a fixed fee accurately without either padding it or listing many exclusions. A capped hourly first year, converted to a fixed fee from year two, is often the fairer arrangement for both sides. If you are moving firms, our guide to switching US UK tax accountants explains what records shorten that first-year learning curve.

What a fixed fee should list

A fixed fee is a promise about a defined list of work. Before you accept one, check that the engagement letter names each of these, or says plainly that it is excluded:

  • The US federal return and every schedule and information form expected, including the foreign tax credit form or foreign earned income exclusion form the firm intends to use.
  • The FBAR, which is filed electronically with FinCEN, not with the tax return, and is due on 15 April with an automatic extension to 15 October (IRS, FBAR).
  • How many PFIC holdings are included. The IRS instructions state that a separate Form 8621 must be filed for each PFIC in which stock is held directly or indirectly (Instructions for Form 8621), so a fee that covers "PFIC reporting" without a number is open-ended. Our explainer on what counts as a PFIC shows why UK funds so often fall into this.
  • Any US state return, and which state.
  • The UK Self Assessment return with its foreign, residence and capital gains pages.
  • Whether replies to routine IRS or HMRC letters about the filed returns are included or billed separately.

Worked example: comparing two quotes for the same client

Illustrative example: all figures below are invented to show the arithmetic. They are not our prices and not a market average.

Jordan is a US citizen living in Manchester, employed on a UK salary, with a UK workplace pension, two UK bank accounts, a Stocks and Shares ISA holding three UK-domiciled funds, and no US state filing. Two firms quote for the 2026 US return and the 2026/27 UK return.

  • Firm A: fixed fee of £3,000 covering the US federal return, FBAR, UK Self Assessment return and up to three PFIC forms. Each extra PFIC form is £150. Property sales are quoted separately.
  • Firm B: hourly at £200 per hour, estimated at 12 to 15 hours (£2,400 to £3,000), no cap, FBAR included.

On the headline numbers Firm B looks cheaper or equal. Now run three versions of Jordan's year through both quotes:

ScenarioFirm A (fixed)Firm B (hourly, £200/hour)
1. Year as expected£3,000£2,400 to £3,000
2. Jordan buys three more ISA funds£3,000 + 3 × £150 = £3,450Extra 4 to 6 hours: £3,200 to £4,200
3. Scenario 2 plus an HMRC letter needing a reply£3,450 + reply billed hourly (say 2 hours = £400) = £3,850Extra 2 hours: £3,600 to £4,600

The lesson is not that fixed fees always win. In a quiet year Firm B is up to £600 cheaper. The lesson is that the hourly quote carries all the overrun risk on Jordan's side, while the fixed quote prices that risk in advance and itemises the add-ons. Jordan's real choice is whether a predictable £3,000 to £3,850 is worth more than a range of £2,400 to £4,600. For most salaried clients who dislike surprise bills, it is. For a client with a very stable year and no new funds, the hourly quote may genuinely cost less.

What the IRS rules say about how tax practitioners charge

Circular 230 puts two limits on fees that matter to clients. First, a practitioner may not charge an unconscionable fee in connection with any matter before the IRS. Second, it restricts contingent fees, defined as fees that depend on whether a tax position avoids challenge or is sustained. The definition expressly includes a fee based on a percentage of the refund reported on a return, or on a percentage of the taxes saved (Circular 230, §10.27).

Circular 230 allows contingent fees only in narrow situations: work on an IRS examination of, or challenge to, an original return; an amended return or refund claim filed within 120 days of receiving written notice of an examination or challenge; a refund claim solely about statutory interest or penalties; and judicial proceedings. Preparing your ordinary annual return is not on that list, so a quote priced as a share of your refund is a reason to walk away.

The IRS repeats the practical point for taxpayers: avoid tax return preparers who base their fees on a percentage of the refund, and use a preparer who has a Preparer Tax Identification Number (PTIN) and signs the return (IRS Topic no. 254). On the UK side, any fee charged by a VAT-registered UK firm to a UK-resident individual normally carries VAT at the standard rate, which GOV.UK lists as 20%; check whether a quote is shown before or after VAT.

Why cross-border fees are often billed in stages

The two filing calendars do not line up, so a single invoice at the end rarely fits. The US tax year is the calendar year. A US citizen living abroad on the regular due date gets an automatic two-month extension to file and pay, to 15 June for calendar-year filers, though interest runs on tax not paid by the regular April due date (IRS, taxpayers abroad). Form 4868 gives an automatic six-month extension of time to file, though, as the IRS puts it, an extension of time to file is not an extension of time to pay (IRS, When to file).

The UK tax year runs from 6 April to 5 April. For the 2025/26 tax year, GOV.UK gives 31 October 2026 for a paper return and 31 January 2027 for an online return and the tax payment, with the second payment on account due on 31 July (GOV.UK, Self Assessment deadlines).

Because the UK tax figure feeds the US foreign tax credit, many firms prepare the UK numbers first, then finalise the US return. Staged billing follows that sequence:

  1. Engagement and deposit: the firm confirms scope, runs identity checks and sends its document request.
  2. US filing stage: billed when the US federal return and FBAR are filed, by 15 June or under the October extension.
  3. UK filing stage: billed when the UK Self Assessment return is filed, before 31 January.
  4. Out-of-scope work: billed separately as it happens, against the hourly rate or cap in the engagement letter.

Staging spreads the cost, but check the dates: a final invoice arriving in January, alongside your own UK balancing payment and first payment on account, is a cash-flow problem worth planning for.

Which events turn a fixed fee into extra charges?

The events that most often move a client outside a fixed fee are those that add forms or decisions: buying or selling property, opening new investment funds, starting a business or side income, moving between US states, a change in UK residence status, a marriage, divorce or new child, and receiving a letter from the IRS or HMRC. Telling your adviser before the event, not after, usually costs less.

A short pre-event email lets the firm say whether the change sits inside the fixed fee, what it will add if not, and whether a decision (for example, which tax year a sale falls in) is still open. After the event, the same work is often a reconstruction, which is slower and therefore dearer on any model.

Correspondence with the IRS deserves its own line. If the IRS opens an examination, the adviser who represents you needs your authority on Form 2848, which the IRS describes as the form used to authorise an individual to represent you before the IRS (IRS, About Form 2848). Representation is almost always outside a fixed preparation fee; see our IRS representation service for how that work is scoped.

How catch-up and streamlined filings are priced

Catch-up work is usually quoted as a project because its size is known once the years are counted. Under the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures, an eligible taxpayer files the most recent three years of US tax returns for which the due date has passed and the most recent six years of FBARs (IRS, taxpayers residing outside the United States). That is nine filings plus the certification, not one return, and a project quote should say how many years, accounts and funds it assumes.

Ask whether the project fee includes the following year's current return. Many catch-up clients assume it does; often it does not, because the current year is a separate annual engagement. Our streamlined filing service page sets out the components of a typical submission.

What people get wrong about US UK tax accountants fees

  • Comparing headline prices with different scopes. A lower quote that excludes the FBAR or caps PFIC forms at one is not cheaper if you need those items.
  • Assuming the fixed fee includes advice. Most fixed fees cover preparing returns from finished facts. Planning a share sale or a move is usually separate.
  • Choosing two firms to save money. Two separate firms each price their own return and neither prices the cross-check between them. Our guide to one firm for US and UK tax returns explains where that gap sits.
  • Ignoring the invoice currency. A quote in dollars paid from a sterling salary moves with the exchange rate.
  • Not asking about price rises. Ask how the fee is reviewed each year and how much notice you will get of a change.

A checklist before you sign an engagement letter

For a clause-by-clause reading of the letter itself, see what a cross border tax preparation engagement letter should cover.

  1. Which pricing model applies to each type of work: returns, advice, correspondence, catch-up?
  2. What exactly does the fixed fee cover, form by form, and what does each add-on cost?
  3. Is there a cap on hourly work, and who must approve going over it?
  4. When will invoices arrive, in which currency, and is VAT included?
  5. Does the preparer have a PTIN and sign the US return?
  6. Is any part of the fee linked to the size of a refund or to taxes saved? If so, ask why.
  7. Who handles IRS and HMRC letters after filing, and on what terms?

Getting a quote that matches your year

The most useful thing you can send a firm before it quotes is a plain list: your income types, accounts, funds, properties, states and any changes planned for the year ahead. That lets it put the predictable work on a fixed fee and name the rest. US/UK Cross Border Tax is a team of US CPAs and UK tax advisers working as one team, with offices in London, Manchester, New York and San Francisco; we prepare US and UK individual tax returns together and set out the scope of each line before work starts. To talk to our US UK tax accountants about your own year, send us that list and we will tell you which parts we can fix in advance.

Frequently asked questions

Do US UK tax accountants charge a fixed fee or by the hour?

Most US UK tax accountants charge a fixed fee for the recurring annual work, meaning the US federal return, the UK Self Assessment return and the FBAR, once they have seen a full year of your paperwork. Advice on one-off questions, IRS or HMRC letters and anything outside the agreed scope is more often billed by the hour, sometimes with a cap agreed in advance.

Why did my cross-border tax fee go up from last year?

A cross-border tax fee usually rises because the facts changed, not the price list. Common causes are a new investment fund that counts as a PFIC, a property sale, a move between US states, a new business, a child born during the year or a change of UK residence status. Ask the firm to show which line of its scope changed and how much each item added.

Is a retainer worth it for US and UK tax work?

A retainer is worth it when you expect several questions or decisions during the year, such as share option exercises, a home purchase, a business restructure or a planned move, and want each one answered before it happens. For someone with a salary, a pension and a few bank accounts, a fixed annual fee plus occasional hourly advice usually costs less than a monthly retainer.

Can a tax accountant charge a percentage of my refund?

You should not agree to one for an ordinary annual return. The IRS's Circular 230 treats a fee based on a percentage of the refund as a contingent fee and permits contingent fees only in narrow cases, such as an IRS examination or a claim about interest or penalties. The IRS also tells taxpayers to avoid preparers who base their fees on a percentage of the refund.

When do US UK tax accountants usually invoice?

Many firms invoice in stages that follow the filing calendar: a deposit when the engagement starts, a payment when the US return is filed by 15 June or 15 October, and a final payment for the UK return before 31 January. Ask for the stage dates in writing so a bill does not arrive while your own tax payment is also due.

Are US UK tax accountants fees billed in pounds or dollars?

That depends on where the firm is set up. A UK firm normally bills in pounds and, if it is VAT registered, adds VAT at the standard rate of 20% for a UK-resident individual. A US firm normally bills in dollars. If you hold money in only one currency, ask for the invoice currency in advance so exchange-rate movements do not change the real cost.

This article is general information, not personal tax advice. Thresholds, rates and deadlines change; confirm current figures on the official sources above and speak to a qualified US/UK tax adviser about your own circumstances.

Written by the US/UK Cross Border Tax team — US CPAs and UK tax advisers, London · Manchester · New York · San Francisco. About us. Last reviewed: November 4, 2026.

Get a quote built around your actual year

Send us your accounts, funds, properties and planned changes, and our US CPAs and UK tax advisers will set out what sits in a fixed fee and what does not, before any work starts.

Get a Fee Quote
Contact US/UK Cross Border Tax

Two Tax Systems, One Team

London Headquarters

4 Crown Place
London EC2A 4BT
United Kingdom

Manchester

CORE
Brown St, Manchester M2 1DH
United Kingdom

San Francisco

600 California St
San Francisco, CA 94108
United States

New York

33 Irving Pl
New York, NY 10003
United States

Start a Conversation