Skip to content
Home/Blog/Choosing an Adviser
Choosing an Adviser

Red Flags When Hiring US/UK Cross Border Tax Specialists

Most warning signs show up before you sign anything: in how an adviser describes who signs, what is in scope and what happens to your foreign accounts. Here are twelve to listen for, and what to ask instead.

Updated:November 9, 2026
Reading Time:10 min read
Navy ledgers, a brass magnifier and a desk bell on pale oak, for red flags when hiring cross border tax specialists
Spotting the red flags when hiring cross border tax specialists starts with checking who signs, what is in scope and what is left out.

The main red flags when hiring cross border tax specialists are an adviser who will not say who signs your US return, a quote with no written list of forms, a promised refund or outcome, silence about foreign accounts, and a UK side that is somebody else's problem. Any one of them is worth a question. Two or three together are a reason to keep looking, ideally before you send a single document.

This guide is for Americans in the UK, British citizens with US ties and anyone else who files in both countries. It is written for the moment you are comparing firms and need to know what a poor fit sounds like. It does not repeat the checklists in our guides on how to choose US/UK cross border tax specialists or what each credential means. It covers the behaviours that should make you stop.

What are the red flags when hiring cross border tax specialists?

The red flags are signals that a firm cannot, or will not, take responsibility for both sides of your return. They fall into three groups: who is accountable, what is promised and what is left out. The table below sets twelve of them against what a better answer looks like.

Red flagWhy it mattersA better answer
"Our team" prepares it, with no name on the signature lineNobody is identified as accountable for the US returnA named signer with a PTIN you can look up
No explanation of US or UK credentials and registrationYou cannot tell who is permitted to act for youA clear statement of who holds what, and where to verify it
Strong on one country, "a contact" for the otherThe join between systems is where mistakes sitOne team, or a named partner with a shared file
A quote with no list of forms and reportsScope disputes start hereA written scope naming every return
A promised refund, or a bigger one than anyone else can getIRS Topic no. 254 warns against itAn explanation of the rules and a range of results
A fee that is a percentage of your refundThe IRS tells taxpayers to avoid itA fixed or hourly fee against a stated scope
No questions about accounts, pensions or fundsFBAR, Form 8938 and PFIC reporting go unscopedA detailed intake about every account and holding
"No tax due, so no FBAR"The FBAR is separate from the tax calculationThe rule cited, with the threshold and deadline
Reluctance to put anything in an engagement letterYou have no written record of what was agreedAn engagement letter before work begins
Requests for your online banking or HMRC loginsProper authorisation exists for this purposeAuthorisation forms for each tax authority
Pressure to skip or shrink a disclosureYou carry the risk if a filing is wrongOptions explained, with consequences
No contact outside filing seasonProblems arrive in any monthA named contact and a stated response time

Who signs, and who answers to the tax authorities?

Anyone paid to prepare a US federal return generally needs a Preparer Tax Identification Number (PTIN), and IRS Topic no. 254 says a reputable preparer enters it, signs your return and gives you a copy. A paid preparer who will not sign is the pattern the IRS calls a ghost preparer, and the IRS warns on its choosing a tax professional page that ghost preparers can disappear with taxpayers' cash and information.

A signature is only half the question. The other half is who can speak for you if the IRS writes. The IRS explains in its guide to preparer credentials that only attorneys, CPAs and enrolled agents have unlimited rights to represent you before the IRS, while Annual Filing Season Program participants have limited rights for returns they prepared and signed. If a firm will not tell you which of its people holds which, that is a red flag in itself. Our guide to hiring a CPA for American expats in the UK goes further on what a licence does and does not certify.

On the UK side, the question changed in 2026. GOV.UK says anyone who deals with HMRC about someone else's tax affairs and is paid for it counts as a tax adviser and must register for an agent services account. Its page on when you need to register as a tax adviser, last updated on 3 September 2026, says most advisers must register now, with later windows for specific types of business. A firm that files UK returns for a fee and tells you "that does not apply to us" owes you a reason. Ask also about anti-money laundering supervision, which you can check on the HMRC supervised business register.

Does the adviser really cover both countries?

A genuine cross border adviser covers both countries on one set of facts, with someone owning the handoffs between them. A one-country firm with a "contact" in the other country is a different thing, and it is one of the most common causes of gaps. Typical phrases to listen for are "we only do the US side, you will need to find someone in London" or "our UK partner will send you a separate quote."

Neither is wrong in itself. Two firms can work if someone is responsible for how the numbers connect, as we explain in accountants for US and UK taxes: one firm or two. The red flag is when nobody will say who owns the seam. Ask who sees both returns before either is filed. If the answer is "nobody", you are buying two single-country engagements and carrying the coordination yourself. For how a joint process looks, see one firm for US and UK tax returns.

What does a vague quote or missing engagement letter tell you?

A vague quote tells you the firm has not decided what it is doing for you. Cross border work has a long list of possible forms: the federal return, a state return, the FBAR, Form 8938, Form 8621 for each PFIC, UK Self Assessment and possibly a foreign tax credit calculation. A quote that says "US and UK tax returns, one price" without naming them leaves each of those open to dispute.

Ask for an engagement letter before work begins, and read it for three things: a list of what is included, a list of what is not, and what triggers an extra charge. Our guide to US UK tax accountants' fees compares fixed, hourly and retainer pricing, and the checklist in choosing a cross border tax advisor covers the letter line by line. Here the red flag is narrower: a firm that will not put the scope in writing at all.

Will the adviser deal with FBAR, Form 8938 and PFICs?

Yes, if they know cross border work, because these are the three reports that single-country engagements most often miss. A good adviser raises them before you do. If your intake consists of "send me your P60 and your US income" and nothing about accounts, pensions or funds, you have not yet been asked the questions that matter.

FBAR

The IRS says a US person must file the FBAR (FinCEN Form 114) when the combined value of foreign financial accounts exceeded $10,000 at any point in the calendar year. It is due on 15 April with an automatic extension to 15 October, and it is filed electronically with FinCEN, separately from the tax return, according to the IRS page last reviewed on 30 July 2026. An adviser who says you can skip it because no tax is due has confused two different obligations.

Form 8938

Form 8938 is a separate statement filed with the income tax return. The IRS says that for taxpayers living abroad, the thresholds are more than $200,000 at year end or $300,000 at any time for a single filer, and $400,000 and $600,000 for joint filers. It adds that Form 8938 does not replace the FBAR. An adviser who treats them as the same form, or who has never heard of the second one, is a flag. See our comparison of FBAR versus Form 8938.

PFICs

A foreign corporation is a passive foreign investment company if at least 75% of its gross income is passive or at least 50% of its assets produce passive income, according to the IRS instructions for Form 8621 (revised December 2025). Whether a particular UK fund falls within that depends on its own facts. A firm that never asks what your ISA or pension holds cannot know. Our guide to the PFIC definition explains why this catches UK-based Americans out.

One caution: be wary of any adviser who says a late FBAR will carry no penalty. Ask for the IRS source for that statement, because penalty outcomes depend on the facts.

What should you do when an adviser promises an outcome?

Treat the promise as the red flag and ask the adviser to explain the rule instead. IRS Topic no. 254 tells taxpayers to be wary of preparers who say they can get bigger refunds than others. Tax outcomes depend on your facts, the treaty and the evidence, so a professional can describe the range but cannot promise the result.

The same applies to fees. The IRS advises avoiding preparers who base their fee on a percentage of the refund or who want a refund deposited into their own account. Circular 230, the rules that govern practitioners before the IRS, also restricts contingent fees in most matters, so a firm that sells on a share of what it saves you should be asked which rule it relies on.

Is it a red flag if they ask for your logins or push you to skip something?

Yes. Both HMRC and the IRS have formal ways for an adviser to act for you, so there is no need to share passwords. GOV.UK explains that when you appoint a tax agent, HMRC sends most Self Assessment correspondence to your authorised person, which shows how much a formal appointment changes. Ask which authorisation forms the firm uses for each country and what each one allows.

Pressure is the other warning. A firm that tells you a disclosure is optional, that an old year can quietly be ignored, or that an account need not be reported has put its convenience ahead of your exposure. A competent adviser lays out the options and consequences and lets you decide. If you are already behind on filings, see our guide on how many years of back taxes an expat has to file before you commit to a plan.

A short test you can run on a first call

  1. Ask who will sign the US return and what credential that person holds.
  2. Ask which UK registration and anti-money laundering supervision the firm has, and where you can verify it.
  3. Ask them to list the forms and reports they will file for you, and what is excluded.
  4. Describe one account, one pension and one fund, and see whether they ask follow-up questions.
  5. Ask what they would do if a prior-year filing turned out to be missing, and listen for options rather than a promise.
  6. Ask for the engagement letter and fee basis in writing before you send documents.

Illustrative example: A hypothetical American working in Manchester receives two quotes. The first firm says "we handle everything for one price, and we will get you the biggest refund." The second names a signer, lists the federal return, FBAR, Form 8938 and UK Self Assessment, asks about her ISA and pension, and states what is excluded. The first quote contains three red flags in one sentence. The second promises no result, and that is exactly why it is easier to trust. The scenario is illustrative only.

What people get wrong about red flags

Treating a low price as the only signal. A cheap quote is not itself a warning, and an expensive one is not proof of quality. What matters is whether the quote names the work.

Treating a large firm as automatically safe. Size does not answer who signs, who handles the UK side or whether the engagement letter names the reports.

Relying on reviews alone. Reviews cannot tell you whether the firm files the FBAR. Verify credentials and registrations directly.

Ignoring your own red flags. If a conversation leaves you unable to say who is doing what, treat that as information. You are entitled to clear answers.

If a firm passes all of this and you later want to move, switching US UK tax accountants mid-year explains how to do it without missing a deadline.

How we approach this

US/UK Cross Border Tax is US CPAs and UK tax advisers working as one team, from London, Manchester, New York and San Francisco. We would rather you tested us against this list than took our word for it. You can read more about our US/UK cross border tax specialists, see what the first 30 days of onboarding involve, or contact us and ask any of the questions above. This article is general information, not advice on your own position.

Frequently asked questions

What are the biggest red flags when hiring a tax adviser for US and UK returns?

The biggest ones are no named person signing the US return, no explanation of who handles the UK side, a quote with no written list of forms, any promise of a particular refund or outcome, and silence on foreign account reporting such as the FBAR and Form 8938. Pressure to hand over online banking logins or to skip a disclosure is a further sign to walk away.

Is it a red flag if my tax preparer does not sign my return?

Yes. The IRS says a reputable preparer enters their PTIN, signs your return and gives you a copy. A paid preparer who leaves the signature box blank is what the IRS calls a ghost preparer. That leaves you as the only person accountable for the return and nobody named to answer questions about how it was prepared.

Should a cross border tax specialist charge a percentage of my refund?

That is a warning sign. IRS Topic no. 254 tells taxpayers to avoid preparers who base their fee on a percentage of the refund. Cross border work is usually priced against a written scope of forms and reports, as a fixed fee or hourly, so you can compare quotes. A fee that rises with your refund rewards the wrong behaviour.

Does a UK accountant need to be registered with HMRC to help me?

Under the 2026 rules, anyone who deals with HMRC about someone else's tax affairs and is paid for it must register with HMRC for an agent services account. Most advisers need to register now, and HMRC has staged windows for particular types of business. Ask the firm whether it has registered, or which window applies to it.

What if my adviser says I do not need to file an FBAR because I owe no tax?

Treat that as a red flag. The FBAR is a reporting obligation separate from your tax return. The IRS says a US person must file when the combined value of foreign financial accounts exceeded $10,000 at any point in the calendar year, whether or not any tax is due. Ask the adviser to show you the rule they are relying on.

How many red flags should make me walk away?

There is no fixed number, because a single serious one, such as a refusal to sign or a promised outcome, can be enough. For milder signs like vague wording, ask for the answer in writing. If two or three signs appear together or the firm will not clarify, keep looking before you share your documents.

This article is general information, not personal tax advice. Thresholds, rates and deadlines change; confirm current figures on the official sources above and speak to a qualified US/UK tax adviser about your own circumstances.

Written by the US/UK Cross Border Tax team — US CPAs and UK tax advisers, London · Manchester · New York · San Francisco. About us. Last reviewed: November 9, 2026.

Test us against this list

Send us your position and ask who signs, what is in scope and what is excluded. We will reply with a written scope for both countries and the fee basis, before you share any documents.

Get a Fee Quote
Contact US/UK Cross Border Tax

Two Tax Systems, One Team

London Headquarters

4 Crown Place
London EC2A 4BT
United Kingdom

Manchester

CORE
Brown St, Manchester M2 1DH
United Kingdom

San Francisco

600 California St
San Francisco, CA 94108
United States

New York

33 Irving Pl
New York, NY 10003
United States

Start a Conversation